ZooKeys | 106: [65=2 1 | (2022) A peer-reviewed open-access journal
A Ree Ean retin #ZooKeys
https:/ / ZOO keys. pensoft.net Launched to accelerate biodiversity research
Taxonomic reassessment of chaetognaths
(Chaetognatha, Sagittoidea, Aphragmophora)
from Korean waters
Seohwi Choo!, Man-Ki Jeong’, Ho Young Soh!?
| Big data Fishery Resource Management Interdisciplinary Program, Chonnam University, Yeosu 59626,
Republic of Korea 2 Department of Smart Fisheries Resources Management, Chonnam National University,
Yeosu 59626, Republic of Korea 3 Department of Ocean Integrated Science, Chonnam National University,
Yeosu 59626, Republic of Korea
Corresponding authors: Ho Young Soh (hysoh@jnu.ac.kr), Man-Ki Jeong (jmgdeux@gmail.com)
Academic editor: Pavel Stoev | Received 7 January 2022 | Accepted 30 May 2022 | Published 21 June 2022
http://zoobank.org/EFA7EF37-2B83-458D-931D-9A53DB31 1472
Citation: Choo S, Jeong M-K, Soh HY (2022) Taxonomic reassessment of chaetognaths (Chaetognatha, Sagittoidea,
Aphragmophora) from Korean waters. ZooKeys 1106: 165-211. https://doi.org/10.3897/zookeys.1106.80184
Abstract
Since the first record of chaetognaths (arrow worms) reported from Korean waters by Molchanov in 1907,
three families, 12 genera and 21 species have been additionally described. Eighteen of the 21 recorded
species have been reported under scientific names different from the latest taxonomic system. This study
aimed to address this issue by conducting a taxonomic re-evaluation of chaetognaths collected from Ko-
rean waters. Furthermore, the taxonomic usefulness of morphological differences in corona ciliata and
distribution of ciliary sense receptors were re-examined using specimens stained with 1% Chlorazol black
E (CBE) solution. This study includes taxonomically-validated voucher specimens of 18 species from
Korean waters. Based on the specimens, re-description including image data and CBE staining pattern,
distribution, ecological information and improved key were provided for each species. However, Decip-
isagitta decipiens, Serratosagitta serratodentata and Sagitta pseudoserratodentata from Korean waters is still
questioned because of the paucity of the voucher specimen and scientific literature.
Keywords
Arrow worms, chaetognaths, East China Sea, key, staining solution, taxonomy, voucher specimens
Copyright Seohwi Choo et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY
4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
166 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Introduction
The chaetognaths are marine mesoplanktonic carnivores present in most marine habi-
tats and play an important role in the food web of pelagic ecosystems comprising con-
necting planktonic organisms of higher trophic levels. They have two sets of retractable
chitinous grasping spines flanking a ventral mouth. They mostly feed on copepods,
cladocerans, amphipods, krill and fish larvae depending on their size and developmen-
tal stage (Vega-Pérez 1995; Kruse et al. 2010). Occasionally, they also feed on organic
debris (Grigor et al. 2020). These arrow-like creatures are of great ecological value, espe-
cially as a major food source for commercial fish, such as sardines and mackerel (Chacko
1949; Park 1970). Chaetognath species are distributed worldwide, including the Pacif-
ic, Atlantic, Indian and Antarctic Oceans. They are found in most of the vertical realms
spanning from the surface to the bottom of the ocean (Miiller et al. 2019; WoRMS
2022). As many species of arrow worm have different distributions depending on water
mass, they have been historically used as research subjects to evaluate the marine en-
vironment (Russell 1936; Tokioka 1940; Bone et al. 1991; Terazaki 1992; Nagai et al.
2006). Their geographic distribution patterns have been used as important biological
indicators to explain environmental physicochemical properties, such as cold current,
warm current and oceanic frontal area (Park 1967; Park et al. 1990, 1991, 1992).
The phylum Chaetognatha was first mentioned as “arrow-shaped worms’ by Slabber
M (1769) and Krohn (1844) reported valuable anatomical features to characterise their
internal organisation, nervous system, testes and chitinous cephalic armature. A com-
prehensive and detailed description of their morphology has been presented by Miiller
et al. (2019). The foundation of modern systematics of Chaetognatha was established by
Ritter-Zahony (1911), who classified 27 species into six genera. Subsequently, the taxo-
nomic categories from family to class were defined by Tokioka (1965a, b), who proposed
an advanced classification system. He classified 58 species into two classes, two orders,
five families and 15 genera. Of the two classes, Archisagittoidea comprises only fossil spe-
cies, while Sagittoidea contains all the present chaetognaths existing today. ‘The latter was
subdivided into two orders, Phragmophora and Aphragmophora, based on the presence
or absence of transversal musculature (i.e. phragms) in the body, respectively. Bieri (1991)
proposed a comprehensive classification system for 114 species belonging to 22 genera
and eight families. To date, the phylum Chaetognatha includes 133 species allocated to
26 genera and eight valid families (including Heterokrohniidae) (Miiller et al. 2019). The
taxonomic categories proposed by Tokioka (1965a, b) and Bieri (1991) are still mostly
valid (WORMS 2022), although recent molecular analyses have invalidated Pterosag-
ittidae family (Gasmi et al. 2014; Nair et al. 2015; Miiller et al. 2019; Peter et al. 2020).
Despite the long taxonomic history of Chaetognatha and its ecological impor-
tance, taxonomic research on Korean species is extremely limited. The first record of
chaetognaths in Korean waters was presented by Molchanov (1907). Subsequently,
Tokioka (1940) reported the geographical distribution of 13 species of order Aphrag-
mophora. Including these 13 species, Park (1967, 1970, 1973) reported brief taxo-
nomic and ecological features of 19 species. The number of chaetognath species in
Korea was finally expanded to 21 by including two species described by Kim (1987).
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 167
For the past 20 years, only ecological studies of chaetognaths in Korean waters have
been carried out, based on these 21 species as indicators of various water masses and
currents near the Korean Peninsula (Park et al. 1990, 1991, 1992; Yoo 1991; Yoo and
Kim 1996, 1997; Nagai et al. 2006). The original descriptions and drawings by Park
(1970) and Kim (1987) are the only studies available on Korean waters; however, both
of them are theses for Doctoral and Master's degrees, respectively, written only in Ko-
rean and are yet to be published. Furthermore, because none of the voucher specimens
of 21 species used for description by Park (1970) and Kim (1987) are available and
the accessible records of five species contain very short descriptions and sketches, it is
difficult to confirm their presence in Korean waters. More importantly, these species
have been reported under scientific names that are different from the latest taxonomic
system. These taxonomic limitations regarding the Korean chaetognath taxa result in
misidentification and low reliability of ecological research using indicator species.
Therefore, in this study, we aimed to accomplish the following: 1) to secure the
first taxonomically verified voucher specimens of chaetognath from Korean waters and
disclose them to public institutions; 2) to create the first comprehensive report of
taxonomic features, including morphology, ecology and image information on Korean
chaetognath species, based on newly-obtained voucher specimens; and 3) to provide
an updated key to species for chaetognath taxa in Korea.
Materials and methods
Analysis of previous literature in Korea
To understand the current status of Korean record on chaetognaths, a total of 14 taxo-
nomic and ecological papers published since 1940 to date were investigated (Tokioka
1940, 1951; Park 1967, 1970, 1973; Park et al. 1990, 1991, 1992; Yoo 1991; Yoo and
Kim 1996, 1997; Terazaki 1998; Nagai et al. 2006; Lee et al. 2016). The distribution
of Korean chaetognath taxa mentioned in literature has been divided into four groups
(the East Sea, Korea Strait, northern East China Sea and Yellow Sea) according to the
physical characteristics of each sea near Korea (Fig. 1). All the mentioned species in
literature (21 species of three genera, most belong to genus Sagitta) belong to order
Aphragmophora, of which, three families, 12 genera and 21 species have been identi-
fied according to the traditional taxonomy conventions (Table 1). We performed a
taxonomical comparative analysis of descriptions in previous literature and the newly-
obtained specimens from Korean waters to confirm the existence of the 21 mentioned
species in Korea, which were recorded in literature without voucher specimens.
Morphological examination
Field surveys were conducted at 20 stations in Korean waters from May 2019 to Au-
gust 2020. Zooplankton collection was carried out from the bottom layer to the sur-
face layer using a conical net (diameter: 0.6 m, mesh size: 200 um) and MOCNESS
168 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
38°N
37°N
36°N
35°N
° o
© KS02
KS01 °
. = S04 oe
34°N ° ® oo i 6
KS06 o
Kso3 r Kse4 Kses o@ KS07
Jejul.
KS08 KS09
33°N @® ° @° o oe .e
KS10
e nECS01 nECs@ECSO3
e @ 6
nEC$04
e
32°N
nECSO5 nECS06
e e
121°E 4122°E 123°E 124°E 125°E 126°E 127°E 128°E 129°E 130°E 131°E 132°E
Figure |. Sampling stations in Korean waters. Empty circles, sampling stations; filled circles, the stations
where the chaetognaths were secured.
(area of mouth: 1 m’, mesh size: 200 um). Samples were fixed with 5% formalin and
the morphological features were observed using a stereo-optical microscope (DS-Fi3,
Nikon, Japan). Furthermore, chaetognath specimens were identified at the species level
by referring to the taxonomic terms suggested by Kapp (1991) and adults were iso-
lated from the identified specimens according to Alvarifo (1967). The quantitative
and qualitative characteristics, based on Gasmi et al. (2014) (Table 2), were photo-
graphed using an optical light microscope equipped with a camera (DS-Fi3, Nikon,
Japan) and analysed using the in-built software (NIS-Elements BR, version: 5.11.00,
Nikon, Japan). Any features that were difficult to observe under the light microscope
(including shape and location of corona ciliata rings, structure of fins and morphologi-
cal patterns on the body surface) were confirmed by staining with Chlorazol black E
(CBE) solution (1% in 95% ethanol and diluted in 3:7 ratio with distilled water prior
to staining). The CBE pattern has been described as per Miiller et al. (2014) (Fig. 2).
To supplement the field specimens obtained in this study, 50 samples (eight genera,
nine species) stored at the National Institute of Biological Resources (NIBR) were used
for taxonomic re-examination. Based on the study by Kapp (1991), the taxonomic
terminology and their abbreviations for chaetognath species identification used in this
study are as follows: AN, anus; AF, anterior fin; AT, anterior teeth; CC, corona ciliata;
CF, caudal fin; COL, collarette; CL, caudal length; EP, eye pigments; GS, grasping
spine; IN, intestine; ID, intestinal diverticula; LF, lateral fin; MO, mouth; OL, ovary
length; O, ovary; PF, posterior fin; PT, posterior teeth; RLZ, rayless zone; SV, seminal
vesicle; TL, total length; TM, transverse muscle; and VG, ventral ganglion.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 169
Table |. Korean chaetognath species list reported in previous studies. The species list consists of Tok-
ioka (1940) Tokioka (1951), Park (1967), Park (1970), Park (1973), Park et al. (1990, 1992), Park et
al. (1991), Yoo (1991), Yoo and Kim (1996), Terazaki (1998), Yoo and Kim (1997), Nagai et al. (2006).
Abbreviation: ES = East Sea; KS = Korea strait; nECS = northern East China Sea; YS = Yellow Sea.
Taxa ES KS nECS YS ES, KS, YS and nECS
Class Sagittoidae
Order Aphragmophora
Family Krohnittidae
Genus Krohnitta Ritter-Zahony, 1910
Krohnitta pacifica (Aida, 1897) e e *
Krohnitta subtilis (Grassi, 1881)
Family Pterosagittidae (not valid)
Genus Pterosagitta Costa, 1869
Pterosagitta draco (Krohn, 1853) e e e
Family Sagittidae
Genus Aidanosagitta Tokioka, 1965
Aidanosagitta crassa (Tokioka, 1938) e e e e
Aidanosagitta neglecta (Aida, 1897)
Aidanosagitta regularis (Aida, 1897) ° ° bg
Genus Decipisagitta Tokioka, 1965
Decipisagitta decipiens (Fowler, 1905) ° ° °
Genus Ferosagitta Kassatkina, 1971
Ferosagitta ferox (Doncaster, 1902)
Ferosagitta robusta (Doncaster, 1902)
Genus Flaccisagitta Tokioka, 1965
Flaccisagitta enflata (Grassi, 1881) e ° ° °
Flaccisagitta hexaptera (D’ Orbigny, 1902)
Genus Mesosagitta Tokioka, 1965
Mesosagitta minima (Grassi, 1881) e ° °
Genus Parasagitta Tokioka, 1965
Parasagitta elegans (Verrill, 1873) ° ° ° °
Genus Pseudosagitta Germain & Joubin, 1912
Pseudosagitta lyra (Krohn, 1853) e e e
Genus Sagitta Guoy & Gaimard, 1827
Sagitta bipunctata Quoy & Gaimard, 1827 ° ° e
Genus Serratosagitta Tokioka, 1965
Serratosagitta pacifica (Tokioka, 1940) ° °
Serratosagitta pseudoserratodentata (Tokioka, 1940) °
Serratosagitta serratodentata e e e
Genus Zonosagitta Tokioka, 1827
Zonosagitta bedoti (Beraneck, 1895) ° ° °
Zonosagitta pulchra (Doncaster, 1902)
Zonosagitta nagae Alvarifio, 1967 ° ° °
Results
General taxonomical characteristics
The size of the chaetognaths belonging to the order Aphragmophora ranged between
5 and 80 mm. Aphragmophora had no transverse muscles in the body. In general, spe-
cies diagnosis in Aphragmophora was mostly based on the size and body appearance,
the morphology of the intestine, the chitinous cephalic armature (shape and number
of grasping spines and teeth) and the shape and position of the corona ciliata, lateral
fins and seminal vesicles.
170 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
f i
|
a 4
Pek \\
be Wn /
} ‘ | f f
; Mw
| ff \
| * \} 1)
J WI HI
( NI Mon
— al 1) he
. | = |
fy
| — | |
| |
. \ i]
| |
f |
os) h|
| |
fe | | r
y | ™
if \
{ | | }
yo? |
{ . / |
} |
] | | |
| |
| J
|
|
le
|
| |
le . |
te |
| ) ul
iin ae
Ly \
a |
\ . |
| |
[| |
Noe |
\ |
“ A ) /
~ | | iy
| }
\} i |
1h |}
1” |
Figure 2. Schematic drawing showing the distribution of the ciliary sense organs (modified from Miiller
et al. 2014) A Ferosagitta robusta B Pterosagitta draco. Colour indicated dorsomedian line (red); dorsolat-
eral line (green); lateral line (blue); receptors on the lateral fin (purple); anterolateral receptors on the tail
fin (yellow); posterior receptors on the tail fin (orange).
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 171
Table 2. Quantitative and qualitative characters of the chaetognaths used in this study (modified after
Gasami et al. 2014).
Quantitative characters Qualitative characters
C1 Transverse muscles (absent/ present) Q1 Total length (min/max)
C2 Body firmness (flaccid/ rigid) Q2 Body/ tail ratio
C3 Body transparency (transparent, opaque, translucent) Q3 Number of anterior teeth
C4 Collarette (absent/ present) Q4 Number of posterior teeth
C5 Number of lateral fins (one pair/ two pairs) Q5 Number of hooks (min/max)
C6 Fin positions. Anterior fins can be present on anterior part of ventral ganglion, middle
of ventral ganglion, end of ventral ganglion, long distance behind the end of the ventral
ganglion.
C7 Comparison of anterior fins and posterior fins size
C8 — Rayless zone in the lateral fins (absent/ present)
C9 Intestinal diverticula (absent/ present)
C10 Type of hooks (gently curved/ gently curved and serrated/ abruptly curved)
C11_ Type of seminal vesicle (elongated, oval, spherical, conical)
C12 Positions of seminal vesicle
C13 Type of eye pigment (E, T, star, H, +, B shaped)
C14 Type of corona ciliata (following Tokioka (1965))
C15 Type of teeth row
C16 Number of teeth row (only anterior row/ only posterior row/ presented both anterior and
posterior)
Transparency of the body
The transparency of the body is related to the development of longitudinal muscles in
the trunk and tail and is a distinguishing characteristic at the generic level (Bieri 1991).
However, the criteria for classifying the transparency of the body were not clear in pre-
vious studies. In this study, body transparency was classified into three types: first, the
transparent type, which has weak and flexible muscles; second, the translucent type,
where the internal organs can be observed from the dorsal side (e.g. digestive apparatus
and ovaries), but the ventral ganglion is not visible; and third, the opaque type with
strong, rigid muscles, with internal organs and ventral ganglion being invisible from
the dorsal side. Representative genera of these categories were Flaccisagitta (Fig. 3A),
Pterosagitta (Fig. 3B) and Aidanosagitta (Fig. 3C), respectively.
500 pm
Figure 3. Appearance of body A transparent and flaccid body (Flaccisagitta enflata) B translucent body
(Pterosagitta draco) C opaque and rigid body (Aidanosagitta crassa).
a2 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Fins
The fins are used for floating and balancing (Hyman 1959). The parts of the body between
the fins and the distribution of the fins on the body are morphological features of all the
species (Duvert and Salat 1990); however, each species has its characteristic fin size and po-
sition. Although fins are easily damaged during the collection and fixation process, they are
conspicuous characteristics of chaetognaths. ‘They are located on the lateral and terminal
parts of the body and their size, location and starting point are key characteristics. In this
study, the number of fins was used as a feature to distinguish families; specimens with one
pair of fins on the lateral sides of the body belonged to the families Krohnittidae and genus
Pterosagitta and those with two pairs of fins belonged to families Sagittidae (Fig. 4A—C).
Another diagnostic character at the genus and species level is the presence of a
rayless zone in the lateral fins. For example, Zonosagitta has a long rayless zone on the
anterior fins, but Adanosagitta does not have a rayless zone on either anterior or pos-
terior fins (Fig. 5A, B). The starting and ending points of the fins are also important
taxonomic features. In general, the anterior fins begin at the anterior, middle or tip of
the ventral ganglion. For instance, the anterior fins of Pseudosagitta and Zonosagitta
begin at the anterior position to the ventral ganglion, while those of Ferosagitta and
Aidanosagitta reach the ventral ganglion. On the contrary, the anterior fins of Flaccisag-
itta are located on the posterior part of the body far from the ventral ganglion.
Figure 4. Three families inhabiting Korean waters A Ferosagitta robusta (Sagittidae) B Pterosagitta draco;
C Krohnitta subtilis (Krohnittidae). Abbreviations: AF = anterior fin; CC = corona ciliata; COL = col-
larette; CF = caudal fin; E = eye; GS = grasping spine; LF = lateral fin; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal
vesicle; VG = ventral ganglion.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water V73
500 pm
Figure 5. Presence and absence of rayless zone on lateral fins A black arrow shows rayless zone on poste-
rior fin (Zonosagitta nagae) B completely rayed fin (Aidanosagitta crassa).
Seminal vesicles
All chaetognaths are hermaphroditic and have both female and male organs. In par-
ticular, the shape and location of seminal vesicles are distinct in different species. Semi-
nal vesicles can be elongated along the lateral side of the tail (Fig. GA) or have a pear,
spherical or conical shape (Fig. 6B—E). Serratosagitta pacifica has a distinct elongated
knob with lateral protuberances. The chaetognath species can also be classified ac-
cording to the location of seminal vesicles between the end of the posterior lateral fin
and the caudal fin. The species can be classified, based on the vesicles that touch both
posterior and caudal fins (Fig. 6A, D), those close to one of the two fins (Fig. 6B, E, F)
and those well-separated from the two fins (Fig. 6C).
Intestinal diverticula
The digestive apparatus of the chaetognath is in a single line from the mouth to the
anus located just anterior to the posterior septum; the intestine extends in the trunk,
but is not present in the tail. Classification can be done, based on the presence or
absence of two intestinal diverticula located in the most anterior part of the intes-
tine. They are clearly observed in the genera Aidanosagitta (Fig. 7A) and. Ferosagitta
(Fig. 7B), but not in Pterosagitta (Fig. 3B) and Zonosagitta (Fig. 7C, D).
174 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
500 pm
500 ym
Figure 6. Shape and position of seminal vesicles A Aidanosagitta regularis (elongated) B Ferosagitta ro-
busta (pear shape) C Pseudosagitta lyra (spherical shape) D Zonosagitta nagae (conical shape) E Flaccisagitta
enflata (spherical shape) F Serratosagitta pacifica (seminal shape with chitinous teeth).
C (
500 pm
500 pm
Figure 7. Intestinal diverticular (shown by white arrow) A Aidanosagitta regularis (present) B Ferosagitta
robusta (present) C Zonosagitta nagae (absent) D Zonosagitta bedoti (absent).
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water ee)
Grasping spines
The grasping spines are laterally attached to the head of chaetognaths and are used
for capturing and swallowing prey. The grasping spines of the family Krohnittidae
are sharply curved, while those of Sagittidae are gently curved (Fig. 8A—C; Tokioka
1965a). The grasping spines of the genus Serratosagitta belonging to Sagittidae are ser-
rated (Fig. 8C; Tokioka and Pathansali 1963).
Anterior and posterior teeth
The number of teeth rows is an important key to distinguish families (Tokioka 1965, b). Sag-
ittidae (including Pterosagitta draco) has two rows of teeth arranged ina comb shape (Fig. 9A),
while Krohnittidae has only one row of anterior teeth arranged in a fan shape (Fig. 9B).
500 um
250 pm
Figure 8. Grasping spine A abruptly curved hooks (Krohnitta subtilis, Krohnittidae) B gently curved
and not serrated hooks (Ferosagitta robusta, Sagittidae) C gently curved and serrated hooks (Serratosagitta
pacifica, Sagittidae).
500 pm
Figure 9. Number and shape of dentition A Ferosagitta robusta (two rows) B Krohnitta subtilis (one row).
176 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Corona ciliata
The corona ciliata is related to the sensory organs, presumably involved in chemorecep-
tion (Bleich et al. 2017) and is observed on the dorsal side of the specimen (Kapp 1991).
It begins behind the eyes in Aidanosagitta regularis and Pterosagitta draco (Fig. 10A, B)
or in front of the eyes in Serratosagitta pacifica and Flaccisagitta enflata (Fig. 10C, D).
The corona ciliata may also extend behind the neck, a short distance in the anterior
trunk region (Fig. 10A, C) or does not exceed the head (Fig. 10D).
D
¥
¥
Ne! =
Figure 10. Position and shape of corona ciliata A Aidanosagitta regularis B Pterosagitta draco © Serra-
tosagitta pacifica D Flaccisagitta enflata.
Systematics
Order Aphragmophora Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Ventral transverse musculature absent, less glandular structures on body
surface. Grasping spines gently or abruptly curved (Tokioka 1965a). Collarette absent,
present or small that is almost absent. Intestinal diverticula absent or present. One or
two rows of teeth, teeth-rows arranged in comb or fan shape. One paired or two paired
lateral fins with or without rayless zone (Alvarifio 1967).
Key to family of Aphragmophora
1 Gyire (patty © babe aly HS. 0 asker Beene Seche undsee isan sari d cee cane ee ha tn chalet Mane 2
- diwarpaltssoislatetal Matsa. ..a5. tenons estan tees ere suse cte Paces te Cath weataeoteu tee eaten A
2 One row of teeth, collarette absent............ Krohnittidae (present in Korea)
= SEW HOWS- OF ECGEL «oooh Be eetnalhs Me tien deaetel eran A A Ee te A es 3
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 177
3 One pair of lateral fins on the tail, Collarette remarkably thick...
Sates, Air I eat rie oe Ay tall Pterosagitta draco (present in Korea)
- One:pairof latéralldinis on the trunk. c..cocecsceneesenesvore cesease Pterokrohniidae
4 Tworows:-of teeth, neck contraction ...c.,.cccdssseccaecdecereasocesetvesees Bathybelidae
"EWOsEOWS ORECCH Mois vncteassseasestwe rest vsancnpvorateces Sagittidae (present in Korea)
Family Krohnittidae Tokioka, 1965
Diagnosis. Small head. Grasping spines abruptly curved. One row of teeth. Collarette
either short or absent. One pair of lateral fins arranged on the posterior trunk and tail.
Genus Kro/nitta Ritter-Zahony, 1910
Diagnosis. Slender and transparent body. Lateral fins on the body and tail with rayless
zone or partially rayed. Intestinal diverticula absent. Seminal vesicles oval or elongated
touching both lateral fins and caudal fins.
Key to species of Krohnitta
1 One pair of fins with rayless zone. Seminal vesicles oval shaped and elongated,
touching both paired fins and caudal fins... eee eee eeeeeeees K. subtilis
- One pair of rayed fins. Seminal vesicles oval shaped and placed dorsally at the
point where: lateral finstinettcatidal TNS i.3.2. 00. deigt paves se caveenspavenn’ K. pacifica
Krohnitta subtilis (Grassi, 1881)
Figs 3C, 4C, 8A, 9B, 11A—D
Spadella subtilis: Grassi, 1883: 16 p., table 1.
Krohnia subtilis: Fowler, 1906: 25-26 p., figs 86-88; Michael 1908: 269-270 p.
Krohnitta subtilis: Burfield & Harvey, 1926: 117 p., figs 45—-50.; Thomson 1947: 22
p.; [okioka 1965: 352-353 p.; Alvarifo 1967: 18-20 p., fig. 9 A—D; Srinivasan
1979: 37-39 p., fig. 21 A—D; Michel 1984: 30 p., fig. 41; McLelland 1989: 158
p., fig. 5A—D; Park et al. 1990: 74-76 p., fig. 52.; Nair et al. 2008: 210 p., table 1.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°30.000'N, 125°54.000'E), 0-90 m depth,
oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895313 (one specimen);
northern East China Sea (33°00.000'N, 127°4.098'E), 0-110 m depth, oblique tow-
ing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895312 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 10.8 and 11.5 mm and tail 27.3—
33.7% of body length. Hooks 8-10. Anterior teeth 14. Slender and transparent body
178 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
A
cc
5000 ym
500 um
Figure | 1. A Krohnitta subtilis (dorsal view) B head C tail D lateral fin. Abbreviations: CC = corona
ciliata; CF = caudal fin; COL = collarette; E = eye; GS = grasping spine; IN = intestine; LF = lateral fin;
RLZ = Ray less zone; SV = seminal vesicle.
(Fig. 11A). Small head. One row of stout teeth arranged in fan shape (Fig. 9B). Col-
larette and intestinal diverticula absent (Fig. 11B). Grasping spine abruptly curved
(Fig. 8A). Round eyes with eye pigments in “E” shape (Fig. 11B). Corona ciliata begin-
ning in front of eyes with round shape (Fig. 11C). Lateral fins 29.4% of body length.
Starting points of lateral fins 54.3% and ending points of lateral fins 82.2% of body
length, respectively. One pair of lateral fins only rayed on outer edge, with forward
ends equidistant from caudal septum (Fig. 11A, E). Caudal fin roughly round in shape
(Fig. 11D). Seminal vesicles elongated with anterolateral-edge-opening touching both
lateral fins and caudal fin (Fig. 11D).
Distribution. ‘This species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth) and mesope-
lagic zones (200-500 m depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans (Pierrot-Bults
and Nair 1991), the Indian water (George 1952) and the Tosa Bay in Japan (Ohnishi
et al. 2014), while in this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0-110 m depth)
of the Korea Strait and northern East China Sea (Fig. 1: stations KSO5 and nECS04).
Ecology. This cosmopolitan species can be found in tropical to temperate waters
(Alvarifo 1967). The temperature ranged between 16.40 and 16.41 °C and salinity
was 34.58 psu at the sampling stations of this study.
Remarks. ‘This species is clearly distinguished from K. pacifica by the presence
of a rayless zone in the lateral fin. Furthermore, the presence of a pair of lateral fins
with a wide rayless zone and a fan-shaped dentition in K. subtilis collected from
Korean waters are consistent with the records of Alvarifo (1967) and Bieri (1991).
However, the location of the corona ciliata (in front of the eyes, Fig 11C) of the
species found in Korean waters was different from that of the previous records
(located behind the eye). No specific pattern was observed through CBE staining
on the body surface.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 179
Krohnitta pacifica (Aida, 1897)
Krohnitta pacifica: Yokioka, 1965: 352-353 p.; Alvarifio 1967: 15-17 p., fig. 7A—E; Michel
1984: 29 p., fig. 40; Kim 1987: 35-36 p., plate 13; Park et al. 1990: 73 p., fig. 51.
Material examined. Northern East China Sea (32°29.420'N, 127°29.654' E), 20—
100 m depth, oblique towing with MOCNESS, Aug 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Slender and transparent body. Small head. Grasping spines abruptly
curved. One row of stout teeth arranged in fan shape. One pair of lateral fins partially
rayed, forward and equidistant from caudal septum. Lateral fins positioned at anterior
end, at level of caudal septum with rayed lateral fins. Caudal fin damaged. Collarette
and intestinal diverticula absent. No seminal vesicle visible.
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of
the northern Indian Ocean (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the Gulf of Mexico (Pierce
1951) and the Japanese coast (Tosa Bay, Sagami and Suruga) (Nagasawa and Marumo
1972; Ohnishi et al. 2014) and, in this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone
(20-100 m depth) of the northern East China Sea (Fig. 1: station nECSO3).
Ecology. An inhabitant of the surface layer of the warm oceanic waters (Tokioka
1940). Mature specimen was reported to be 6-8 mm in length (Alvarifo 1967). The
temperature range in the sampling stations of this study was 18.49—28.84 °C and salin-
ity range was 30.71-34.59 psu.
Remarks. Only immature individuals could be collected in this study. The speci-
mens of K. pacifica we observed had one pair of fins and the structure of the fin was
rayed, except for the base part close to the body. These were distinct characteristics of K.
pacifica that differentiated it from K. subtilis. Since seminal vesicles were not observed in
all observed Korean specimens, they were classified as immature stage (Alvarifio 1967).
Family Pterosagittidae Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Wide head. ‘Two rows of teeth. Collarette wide and extending through full
body. One pair of rayed lateral fins located on the tail. Intestinal diverticula absent.
Only one genus has been described within this family: Pterosagitta (Costa, 1869).
Remarks. A previous phylogenetic study reported that Pterosagittidae is geneti-
cally quite close to Sagittdae (Gasmi et al. 2014; Nair et al. 2015; Peter et al. 2020;
Miller et al. 2019). In this study, a recent research paper was reviewed and Pterosag-
ittidae was marked as invalid (Table 1).
Key to the species of Pterosagitta
1 One pair of rayed lateral fins on the tail. Collarette extremely thick and ex-
tends from head to seminal vesicles. Seminal vesicles oval-shaped and elon-
gated, touching. both lateralsiins-and*catidal Tri.e..5..c0.5 scence ra'sscosenss P. draco
180 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Pterosagitta draco (Krohn, 1853)
Figs 3B, 4B, 10B and 12A—D
Spadella draco: Grassi, 1883: 15 p.; Beraneck 1895: 154 p.; Aida 1897: 20 p., fig. 12;
Doncaster 1902: 214-215 p.
Pterosagitta draco: Michael, 1919: 264-265 p., table 18; Thomson 1947: 22-23 p.;
Tokioka 1965: 351-352 p.; Alvarifio 1967: 21-22 p., fig. 11A—D; Srinivasan
1979: 34-35 p., fig. LWA-E; Michel 1984: 29 p., fig. 5; Kim 1987: 33-34 p., plate
12; Park et al. 1990: 71-73 p., fig. 50.
Material examined. Northern East China Sea (32°30.000'N, 127°5.100'E), 0-120
m depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895299 (one
specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 6.5 and 9.1 mm and tail 38.4—
40.1% of body length. Hooks 8. Anterior teeth 10 and posterior teeth 12. Rigid and
translucent body (Fig. 12). Wide and angular head (Fig. 12). Wide collarette extend-
ing over entire body and reaching anterior of seminal vesicles (Fig. 12A. C). Rec-
tangular eyes with “T” shaped eye pigments (Fig. 12B). Intestinal diverticula absent
(Fig. 3B). Lateral fins 20.7% of body length. Starting point of lateral fins 65.2% and
ending points of lateral fins 86.3% of body length, respectively. One pair of lateral fins
triangular-shaped and completely rayed, with forward ends at level of caudal septum
(Fig. 12A, D). Seminal vesicles posteriorly elongated with anterior knob touching
lateral fins (Fig. 12C—D). Eggs reaching middle of body. Corona ciliata anteriorly
opened with horseshoe shape beginning in neck region and ending just behind eyes
(Figs 10B, 124A).
Distribution. This species is located in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth) and mes-
opelagic zones (200-500 m depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans (Pierrot-
Bults and Nair 1991), the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of the Caribbean Sea
(Michel, 1984), the coastal waters surrounding India (George 1952) and the Tosa Bay
in Japan (Ohnishi et al. 2014). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0—
120 m depth) of the northern East China Sea (Fig. 1: station nECS02).
Ecology. This species is widely distributed in warm water masses and appears all
year round in Korean waters, except in the Yellow Sea (Kim 1987). The temperature
range of the Caribbean Sea was reported as 22—29 °C, and salinity range was 33-38
psu (Michel 1984). At the sampling stations of this study, the temperature ranged be-
tween 15.83—28.80 °C and salinity ranged between 31.38-34.60 psu.
Remarks. The largest specimen collected in this study was 9.1 mm in length,
which was at stage 4 maturity. It was smaller than the specimen from New Zealand
(16 mm) reported by Lutschinger (1993). It had characteristics consistent with the
Pterosagitta draco reported from the Pacific (Alvarifio 1967; Michel 1984), such as the
presence of two rows of teeth, one pair of lateral fins, a corona ciliata located between
the back of the eye and the neck and a broad collarette extending from the head to
seminal vesicles. We observed one specimen for CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 181
line, 8 dots; dorsolateral line, 25 dots; lateral line, 10 dots; receptors on the lateral
fin, 2 dots; anterolateral receptors on the caudal fin, 3 dots; posterior receptors on the
caudal fin, 6 dots.
Figure 12. A Prerosagitta draco (dorsal view) B head C tail D lateral fin. Abbreviations: CC = corona
ciliata; COL = collarette; E = eye; LF = lateral fin; PT = posterior teeth; SV = seminal vesicle.
Family Sagittidae (Claus & Grobben, 1905)
Diagnosis. ‘Two rows of stout teeth arranged in comb shape. Two pairs of lateral fins
on the trunk and tail.
Key to genus of Sagittidae
1 Serrated grasping spines ........sceceeeseeeeeee Serratosagitta (present in Korea)
— INGHEeSerratedeoras pitte Spies or... Mehace centers nscrectsbtiedansenstten sheet enteheasbes 2
2 PIAGET DOC Ye ca, cette Dist ene ee tate Mehr on te a hsacie a tiet Mane hhc Aeemantete coral. 3
- RGGTORBOR Vc ti.hrut tins uti naeleegtattus ola benetaek esac Miata tantnubtiehier tase tat 6
3 Ta tes rina wliverticula presente t.5..t. 8d aa s.. Mem echoes Seats ed Ale 4
- Iirestinal daverticulayabsent.¥. 2.x ceccte oe eee oe Se 5
4 Anterior fins beginning at the middle of ventral ganglion, the seminal vesicle
closer;totlateralfunssthianicattelal At cca tere teostsaree osaicleseeetaca les Decipisagitta
- Anterior fins beginning between ventral ganglion and caudal septum, the
seminal vesicle well-separated from lateral fins, but touching caudal fins.......
FR ee IA OE Ue SEF Ro Mesosagitta (present in Korea)
182
Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Anterior fins beginning far behind the end of the ventral ganglion................
gor tenants net apchenanteley athe enapetasts beens Flaccisagitta (present in Korea)
Anterior fins beginning at the end of ventral ganglion 0... elie eeeeeeseereees
Lach Sy SPE, 1 PYA A eeten, 0 Uris ia Paar etn at Pseudosagitta (present in Korea)
Watesritvall "oly ert cullapyteS@it rns venue hea tence wns act nat Se vnettensa aenmeeuserechst et paue debit 7.
lnitestinal civerticulacalsenteS\. xen cese ete et. Bee en ee eee 9
RG HALelbel PESGE Ib ahh OR eas att son Mie esa lta valent ea Ment onder JMR Saat lath ols 8
@ollaretteand rayless:zone onlateral fitis<absenit ...ss.s-cnsvens-cneee oS teevansests eines
ih Loree erey ee hoot ei bei | 5 tall ten 4, eem Pe” ie Parasagitta (present in Korea)
The head width greater than body width, short collarette, the rayless zone on
lateral fins present, the corona ciliata beginning before the eye........... cee
Be teseslaeh tt te lcoky ste sires fen tet eels caeareate tt gant dabuatets Ferosagitta (present in Korea)
The head width smaller than body width, well-developed collarette, com-
pletely rayed lateral fins, the corona ciliata beginning behind the eye............
UN HE sacs ME Sk red Oe, dae decane d ears et ee nt Aidanosagitta (present in Korea)
Anteriorpart-onlareral fits-with tay] ess ZO Cvs. cocen creccuinsece exenieoeser cone secnen
EP chen Erase Mears) Sessee Rah ag Re Lee ie erases Cane Zonosagitta (present in Korea)
Rayless zone on lateral fins absent... Sagitta (present in Korea)
Genus Serratosagitta Tokioka & Pathansali, 1963
Diagnosis. Intestinal diverticula either absent or present. Grasping spines serrated.
Two rows of teeth. Two pairs of lateral fins either with rayless zone or completely rayed.
Key to species of Serratosagitta
1
Intestiinalidivertictla ab sents ff Salve ace Mvecet cede saa Mall Ot, wesc Onde and geet 2
Intestinal idivettioulaspresetat a. 2.csc.bexactvcgstesuteesfansteusssavperetytavesonasifeaeete caches 3
Seminal vesicles with forward elongated knob and teeth-like appendages
forming 5—10 distal protrusions anteriorly, well-separated from caudal fin
but touching posterior fins, the posterior fins and anterior fins of almost same
Teas an). Maseed carter hatsoatatl natch atsehasle tedhs buelsonadlidedten tasenicnddttine nae dane S. pacifica
Seminal vesicles touching the posterior fins and caudal fin, the posterior fins
longer than AnterlOb TINS -cecerecn vee cone reecvetonrcyeteentvetevrenetars S. serratodentata
Seminal vesicles well-separated from caudal fin, but touching posterior fins, pos-
terior fins and anterior fins of almost same length.......S. pseudoserratodentata
Serratosagitta pacifica (Tokioka, 1940)
Figs OF, 8C, 10C, 13A-E
Sagitta serratodentata pacifica: Yokioka, 1959: 72-80 p., fig. 10, table 10; Park et al.
1990: 52-54 p. figs 31, 32.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 183
Sagitta pacifica: Alvariho, 1961: 71 p., fig. A, B, table 2; Alvarifo 1967: 36-39 p., fig.
22A—D; Pierrot-Bults 1974: 221-222 p., fig. 6; Francisco 1977: 226-229 p., plate
1; Srinivasan 1979: 27-29 p., fig. 15A—G; Kim 1987: 18-20 p., plate 3.
Serratosagitta pacifica: Tokioka, 1965: 345-346 p.; Lutschinger 1993: 30-31 p., fig.
15 A-B.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°24.504'N, 127°54.600'E), 0-50 m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, May 2019, NIBRIV0000895311 (two specimens);
Korea Strait (33°33.600'N, 127°34.002'E), 0-96 m depth, oblique towing with coni-
cal net, Feb 2020 (one specimen); northern East China Sea (32°33.000'N, 126°30.000
E), 0-100 m depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895310
(three specimens); northern East China Sea (32°00.000'N, 127°4.098'E), 0-120 m
depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, two specimens.
Description. Total body length ranged within 11.8 and 13.7 mm. Tail 23.4—
24.9% of body length. Hooks 6—7. Anterior 10-13 and posterior teeth 16-25. Rigid
and opaque body (Fig. 13A). Small head (Fig. 13A, B). Grasping spines serrated
on edge (Fig. 8C). Collarette absent (Fig. 10C, 13A). Rectangular eyes with “T”
shaped eye pigments (Fig. 13B). Intestinal diverticula absent (Fig. 10C). Anterior
fins spanned 21.9% of body length. Anterior fins completely rayed beginning be-
tween ventral ganglion and caudal septum. Starting point of anterior fins 34.6%
and ending points of anterior fins 55.1% of body length, respectively (Fig. 13A, D).
Posterior fins 26.2% of body length and 1.2 times longer than anterior fins. Starting
points of posterior fins 63.7% and ending points of posterior fins 89.7% of body
length, respectively. Posterior fins well-separated from anterior fins (Fig. 13A, E).
Caudal fin triangular shaped (Fig. 13A, C). Seminal vesicles touched or closed to
lateral fins and well-separated from tail fin (Fig. 13C) with elongated knob facing
obliquely forward and teeth-like appendages forming 5—10 distal protrusions. Eggs
reached anterior of anterior fins. Collarette beginning in front of eyes and extended
over neck (Fig. 10C, 13A).
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth) and mes-
opelagic zones (200-500 m depth) of the Pacific and Indian Oceans (Alvarifio 1967;
Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the epipelagic zone of Red Sea, Californian waters
(Pierrot-Bults 1976) and the Tosa Bay in Japan (Ohnishi et al. 2014). In this study, it
was distributed in the epipelagic zone (0-50 m depth) of the Korea Strait and northern
East China Sea (Fig. 1: stations KS06, KSO7, nECSO1 and nECS04).
Ecology. This species mainly inhabits Indo-pacific warm-water masses (Bieri 1959).
In the Pacific Ocean, it is a known indicator species of the Kuroshio Water Mass (Kim
1987). In this study, the temperature range of sampling locations was 16.37—20.57 °C
and salinity ranged between 34.48—34.61 psu.
Remarks. ‘The seminal vesicles are used as an important morphological feature to iden-
tify the genus Serratosagitta. S. serratodentata has thick collarette tissue in front of the sem-
inal vesicles and two projections at the anterior-lateral corner. The seminal vesicles touch
the end of posterior fins (Alvarifio 1961). The seminal vesicles of S. pseudoserratodentata
have one projection at the front corner, with small teeth at the anterior end. The seminal
184 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
ies a
Figure 13. A Serratosagitta pacifica (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbrevia-
tions: AF = anterior fin; AT = anterior teeth; CC = corona ciliata; COL = collarette; E = eye; PF = posterior
fin; PT = posterior teeth; SV = seminal vesicle.
vesicles are well-separated from the posterior fins and caudal fin (Alvarifio 1961). In the
S. pacifica (nine specimens), the number of protrusions vary between 5 and 10. ‘The in-
ner serrated row of the grasping spine and the “teeth cells” forming protrusions at the
anterior margin of the seminal vesicles were consistent with previous records (Alvarifo
1967; Pierrot-Bults 1976). We observed three specimens for CBE staining pattern: dor-
somedian line 43 dots; dorsolateral line, 54—69 dots; lateral line, 24 dots; receptors on the
lateral fin, 10 dots; anterolateral receptors on the caudal fin, 2 dots; posterior receptors on
the caudal fin, 3-4 dots. The dorsomedian dots are patterned as small spots that cross the
centre of the body and larger symmetrical spots on dorsolateral line dots.
Genus Mesosagitta Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Flaccid and opaque body. Collarette absent. Intestinal diverticula pre-
sent. Grasping spine gently curved and not serrated. Intestinal diverticula present.
The anterior fins begin between ventral ganglion and caudal fin and are shorter than
posterior fins.
Mesosagitta minima (Grassi, 1881)
Spadella minima: Grassi, 1883: 15 p.
Sagitta minima: Aida, 1897: 15 p., fig. 5; Michael 1908: 74 p.; Michael 1919: 248-
249 p.; Tokioka 1940: 5 p.; Thomson 1947: 19 p.; Prado 1961: 39-41 p.; Alvarifio
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 185
1967: 59-61 p., figs 36, 37; Ducret 1974: 166 p., table.1; Srinivasan 1979: 24—
26 p., fig. 13; Michel 1984: 25-26 p., fig. 34; McLelland 1989: 163 p., table.1,
figs 8D, 12D.
Material examined. Northern East China Sea (32°29.420'N, 127°29.654'E), 20—
100 m depth, oblique towing with MOCNESS, Aug 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Small head. Two pairs of lateral fins with rayless zone. Intestinal
diverticula small. Seminal vesicles divided into a small anterior knob and elongated
posterior part and well-separated from posterior fins, but touching caudal fin. Corona
ciliata elongated oval-shaped beginning in neck.
Distribution. This cosmopolitan species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m
depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991) and
the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of the Japan coast (Sagami Bay and Suruga Bay)
(Nagasawa and Marumo 1972). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone
(20-100 m depth) of the northern East China Sea (Fig.1, station nECS03).
Ecology. Mesosagitta minima is abundant in mixed waters of the western North
Atlantic Ocean (Pierce 1951). Mature specimens ranged within the size of 7-8 mm
(Park 1970). The temperature range measured in the sampling stations was 18.49-
28.84 °C and salinity range was 30.71—34.59 psu.
Remarks. Only immature individuals could be collected in this study. We easily
distinguished MZ. minima amongst the collected specimens by the relatively small head
and unique body shape that thickens towards the tail. These Korean specimens were
classified as immature because seminal vesicles and ovaries were absent and undevel-
oped short eggs (mentioned in description of Alvarifo (1967) as a feature of the second
stage of development) were observed in the body.
Genus Flaccisagitta Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Transparent or translucent body. Collarette absent. Intestinal diverticula
absent. The anterior fins begin at a far distance behind the end of the ventral ganglion.
Seminal vesicles spherical shaped.
Key to species of Flaccisagitta
1 Large body (> 40 mm), small eggs reaching the neck... E. hexaptera
- Small body (< 20 mm), large eggs reaching the anterior part of posterior fins
BE, oi Miniinicn te ettgeatldhen Menase nat ore ante pica este stn oblate pics nah Moabetewntcant EF enflata
Flaccisagitta enflata (Grassi, 1881)
Figs 3A, GE, 10D and 14A-E
Spadella enflata: Grassi, 1883: 13 p., fig. 7.
186 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Sagitta inflata: Ritter-Zahony, 1908: 13-15 p., fig. 4A—D; Srinivasan 1979: 18-19 p.,
fig. 9.
Sagitta enflata: Aida, 1897: 15-16 p., fig. 6; Fowler 1906: 69 p., figs 9-17; Ritter-Zah-
ony 1909: 791-792 p.; Michael 1919: 242-244 p., fig. 28, table 1; Burfield and
Harvey 1926: 95-96 p., fig. 5; Pierce 1951: 221-222 p., fig. 4, table 12; Alvarifio
1967: 29-34 p., fig. 17A-G; Michel 1984: 18-19 p., figs 2, 20.
Sagitta enflata f. gardineri: Tokioka, 1959: 91-92 p., table 19
Flaccisagitta enflata: McLelland, 1989: 159 p., figs 7A and 12B
Material examined. Korea Strait (32°59.175'N, 124°29.595'E), 20-25 m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, Nov 2019, NIBRIV0000895309 (three specimens);
northern East China Sea (32°0.000'N, 127°4.098'E), 0-110 m depth, oblique towing
with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895308 (four specimens); northern East
China Sea (32°30.000'N, 126°30.000'E), 0-100 m depth, oblique towing with coni-
cal net, Feb 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 12.7 and 15.4 mm. Tail 14.1-
17.6% of body length. Hooks 8-10. Anterior teeth 6-10 and posterior teeth 10-17, re-
spectively. Transparent body, inflated towards middle (Fig. 14). Triangular-shaped head
(Fig. 14A). Collarette absent (Figs 3A, 10D). Blunt teeth (Fig. 14B). Round eyes with
star-shaped eye pigments (Fig. 14B). Intestinal diverticula absent (Fig. 10D). Anterior
fins 17.0% of body length. Anterior fins began at middle of body at far distance back of
ventral ganglion and partially rayed. Starting points of anterior fins 43.7% and ending
Figure 14. A Flaccisagitta enflata (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbrevia-
tions: AF = anterior fin; AT = anterior teeth; CC = corona ciliata; E = eye; IN = intestine; PF = posterior
fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 187
points of anterior fins 64.4% of body length, respectively (Fig. 14A, D). Posterior fins
20.5% of body length and 1.2 times longer than anterior fins. Starting points of posteri-
or fins 71.9% and end points of posterior fins 92.5% of body length, respectively. Poste-
rior fins well-separated from anterior fins (Fig. 14A, E). Caudal fin roundish, fan-shaped
and fully rayed (Fig. 14C). Seminal vesicles touching caudal fin, but separated from
posterior fins, spherical in shape with rupture in middle in mature specimen (Fig. 14C).
Corona ciliata beginning in front of eyes and reaching neck (Figs 10D, 14A, 14B).
Distribution. This cosmopolitan species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m
depth) and mesopelagic zones (200-500 m depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic
Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the coastal area of Japan (Tosa Bay; Ohnishi et
al. 2014) and the epipelagic zone (0-150 m depth) of the Korea Strait (Park 1970). In
this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0-110 m depth) of the northern East
China Sea (Fig. 1: stations KS08, nECSO1 and nECS04).
Ecology. This is used as an indicator species of warm currents in water surrounding
Korea (Park 1970). The temperature range in the sampling stations was 16.52—28.80 °C
and the salinity range was 28.96—33.22 psu.
Remarks. The transparent and flaccid body, star-shaped eye pigments and semi-
nal vesicle morphology were consistent with those recorded in previous studies by
Alvarifo (1967) and Nagasawa (1976). Two types of Korean Flaccisagitta enflata
have been reported, a small type: 10—20 mm long and a large type: 20-28 mm long
(Park 1970). In this study, only the small type (< 20 mm) of F enflata was collected.
We observed seven specimens for CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian line, 12 dots;
dorsolateral line, > 150 dots; ambiguous lateral line, receptors on the lateral fin, 2
dots (easily damaged); anterolateral receptors on the caudal fin, 4 dots; posterior re-
ceptors on the caudal fin, 7 dots. The pattern of dorsomedian dots lined up behind
the ventral ganglion and the pattern of dorsolateral dots intensively scattered ahead
of ventral ganglion.
Flaccisagitta hexaptera (d’Orbigny, 1836)
Fig. 1SA-E
Sagitta hexaptera: Conant, 1896: 213 p.; Aida 1897: 14 p., fig. 3; Fowler 1906: 70 p.,
figs 30-33; Ritter-Zahony 1908: 9-10 p., figs 3, 3A, 3B; Ritter-Zahony 1909:
789-790 p.; Ritter-Zahony 1911: 2-3 p.; Burfield and Harvey 1926: 95-96 p.,
figs 6-9; Tokioka 1959: 382-383 p., fig. 21; Alvarifo 1967: 27-29 p., fig. 16A-I;
Srinivasan 1979: 14-16 p., fig. 7A—G; Michel 1984: 21p., fig. 25.
Flaccisagitta hexaptera: McLelland, 1989: 159-160 p., figs 7B, C and 12A.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°24.504'N, 127°54.600'E), 0-50 m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, Nov 2019, NIBRIV0000895298 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 15 and 49 mm. Tail 19-24% of
body length. Hooks 4-11. Anterior teeth 2—4 and posterior teeth 2—9, respectively.
188 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Large and translucent body (Fig. 15). Intestinal diverticula absent (Fig. 15B). Col-
larette absent (Fig. 15A). Eyes “D” shaped with “I” shaped eye pigments (Fig. 15B).
Anterior fins short, beginning at middle of body between ventral ganglion and caudal
septum, round-shaped and partially rayed (Fig. 15A, D). Posterior fins well-separated
from anterior fins and partially rayed (Fig. 15A, E). Caudal fin roundish triangular-
shaped and completely rayed (Fig. 15A, C). Seminal vesicles spherical with anterolat-
eral edge opening (Fig. 15C). Seminal vesicle touching or close to tail fin and well-sep-
arated from lateral fins (Fig. 15C). Eggs reaching forward end of anterior fins. Corona
ciliata beginning in front of eyes and reaching neck (Fig. 15B).
Distribution. This cosmopolitan species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth)
and mesopelagic zones (200-500 m depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans
(Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), in the Indian coast (George 1952), the Tosa Bay in Japan
(Ohnishi et al. 2014), the Korea Strait and south of East Sea (Park 1970). In this study, it
was found in the epipelagic zone (0-50 m depth) of the Korea Strait (Fig. 1: station KS07).
Ecology. ‘This species is considered as an indicator species of the Kuroshio warm current
and fully-grown adults inhabit depths of < 200 m (Park 1970). In this study, individuals un-
der Stage 3 were mainly found between the Jeju Straits (0-100 m depth). The temperature
range in the sampling stations was 16.52—20.57 °C and salinity range was 34.48—34.61 psu.
Remarks. Though mainly immature individuals were reported in previous studies
from Korea, in this study, adults longer than 40 mm were collected for the first time.
The Korean species was consistent with those found in previous studies by Alvarifo
(1967) and Michel (1984) in terms of body size, length and shape of the egg, presence
of small and round anterior fins in the middle of the body and the absence of bridge
connecting the anterior and posterior fins. As the adult Flaccisagitta hexaptera is large
A
Figure 15. A Flaccisagitta hexaptera (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbrevia-
tions: AF = anterior fin; CC = corona ciliata; E = eye; IN = intestine; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 189
(> 20 mm), it can be difficult to distinguish the adult Flaccisagitta enflata from the im-
mature F hexaptera. However, it is possible when noting that the eggs of F hexaptera
are long and thin, whereas those of F enflata are large and short. Another feature
relevant for the diagnosis of F hexaptera is the number of conspicuous anterior teeth
which never exceed four, while it is eight in F enflata. No specific pattern was observed
through CBE staining on the body surface.
Genus Pseudosagitta Germain & Joubin, 1912
Diagnosis. Flaccid and transparent body (but more opaque than Flaccisagitta). Col-
larette absent. Intestinal diverticula absent. Two pairs of lateral fins partially rayed and
connected with a tegumentary bridge. Anterior fins beginning at the rear end of ventral
ganglion and longer than posterior fins.
Pseudosagitta lyra (Krohn, 1853)
Figs 6C, 16A—E
Sagitta lyra: Aida, 1897: 15 p., fig. 4; Fowler 1906: 33 p.; Ritter-Zahony 1908: 10-13
p., fig. LA-E; Burfield and Harvey 1926: 98 p., figs 18-24; Thomson 1947: 10-11
p.; Alvarifo 1967: 23-26 p., fig. 14A—O; Lea 1955: 28-30 p., plate 3; Srinivasan
1979: 20-21 p., fig. 1OA-F; Michel 1984: 22-23 p., fig. 27.
Flaccisagitta lyra: McLelland, 1989: 162 p., figs 7D, 7E and 12C.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°48.924'N, 126°48.666'E), 40-70 m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, May 2019, NIBRIV0000895307 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 16.0 and 60.0 mm. Tail 14-20%
of body length. Hooks 8-9. Anterior teeth 4—9 and posterior 8—10, respectively. Large,
flaccid and opaque body (Fig. 16). Intestinal diverticula absent (Fig. 16B). Collarette
absent (Fig. 1G6A and B). Eyes square shaped with “H” shaped eye pigments (Fig. 16B).
Anterior fins beginning at ventral ganglion, anterior of anterior fins with ray less zone
and angular shape, conspicuously longer than posterior fins (Fig. 16A, D). Posterior
fins with rayless zone connected with anterior fins by tegumentary bridge (Fig. 16A, E).
Caudal fin roundish and completely rayed (Fig. 16C). Eggs reaching middle of poste-
rior fins (Fig. 16A). Corona ciliata not clear (Fig. 16B). Seminal vesicles spherical and
opening in middle of edge (Fig. 16C). Seminal vesicles touching neither of posterior
or caudal fins, located closer to posterior fins (Fig. 16C).
Distribution. This species is found in the mesopelagic (500—1,000 m depth) and bathy-
pelagic zones (1,000—2,000 m depth) of the Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans (Pierrot-
Bults and Nair 1991) and the Tosa Bay in Japan (Ohnishi et al. 2014). In this study, it was
distributed in the epipelagic zone (40-70 m depth) of the Korea Strait (Fig. 1, station KS06).
Ecology. This species has a high prevalence in warm waters (Park 1970). In
this study, specimens collected around Jeju Island were mainly distributed at water
190 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
= \™e
ete. 5
or
1000 pm
Figure 16. A Pseudosagitta lyra (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbreviations:
AF = anterior fin; E = eye; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
depths > 50 m. The temperature range in the sampling stations was 16.47—21.34 °C
and the salinity range was 34.17—34.52 psu.
Remarks. In Korean specimens, the position and length of the fins, distance be-
tween the anterior and posterior fins and shape of the seminal vesicles were morpho-
logically consistent with the previous records of Pseudosagitta lyra (Alvarifo 1967;
Michel 1984; Lutschinger 1993). As one of the larger species of arrow worm, P lyra
reaches a maximum size of 42 mm (Michel 1984; Lutschinger 1993). However, the
largest of the Korean specimens collected in this study was 60 mm in length. Pseudos-
agitta scrippsae can be easily confused with P /yra, with similar size and position and
shape of the fins and seminal vesicles. However, P scrippsae can be differentiated by
the presence of a distinct collarette around the neck (Chihara and Murano 1997). No
specific pattern was observed through CBE staining on the body surface.
Genus Parasagitta Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Slender and either opaque or translucent body. Collarette absent or small
(almost absent). Intestinal diverticula present or absent. Grasping spines not serrated.
Two rows of teeth. Two pairs of lateral fins completely rayed.
Parasagitta elegans (Verrill, 1873)
Fig. 17A-E
Sagitta elegans: Verrill, 1873: 332-333 p.; Conant 1896: 211-212 p.; Fowler 1906:
31-32 p.; Lea 1955: 22-28 p., plate 3.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 191
Material examined. East Sea (37°33.198'N, 131°14.598'E), 0-100 m depth, oblique
towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895306 (five specimens).
Description. Total body length ranged between 32.5 and 37.0 mm. Tail 14.7—
20.6% of body. Hooks 11-12. Anterior teeth 9-10 and posterior teeth 22-29, re-
spectively. Rigid and opaque body (Fig. 17). Collarette absent (Fig. 17A). Intestinal
diverticula present, but not obvious. Anterior fins 18.8% of body length. Anterior
fins beginning at middle of ventral ganglion and partially rayed. Starting points of
anterior fins 38.5% and ending points of anterior fins 57.5% of body length, respec-
tively (Fig. 17D). Posterior fins 22.3% of body length and 1.2 times longer than an-
terior fins. Starting points of posterior fins 67.7% and ending points of posterior fins
88.7% of body length, respectively. Posterior fins well-separated from anterior fins
(Fig. 17E). Seminal vesicles elongated (Fig. 17C). Caudal fin roundish triangular-
shaped (Fig. 17C). Square eyes “+” shaped eye pigments (Fig 17B). Corona ciliata
beginning in front of eyes and expanding to anterior trunk (Fig. 17B).
Distribution. This species is found in the Epipelagic (0-200 m depth), mesope-
lagic (200-500 m depth) and bathypelagic zones (1000-2000 m depth) of the Pacific,
Indian and Atlantic Oceans (Terazaki 1998; Choe and Deibel 2000) and the epipelagic
and mesopelagic zones of the East Sea (Park 1970). In this study, it was found in the
epipelagic zone (0-100 m depth) of the East Sea.
Ecology. A cold-water species, P elegans is mainly found in the northern part of
the Pacific Ocean (Bieri 1959). The spawning season is winter and fully mature indi-
viduals are > 30 mm in length (Park 1970). The temperature range in the sampling
stations of this study was 8.20—11.97 °C and the salinity range was 34.1 1-34.20 psu.
Remarks. The absence of a rayless zone in the anterior and posterior fins and a
collarette in anterior body and the presence of small seminal vesicles extending along
A
1000 pm
Figure 17. A Parasagitta elegans (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbreviations:
AF = anterior fin; E = eye; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
192 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
the body in the Korean specimens of Parasagitta elegans were consistent with previous
records (Chihara and Murano 1997). Adult specimens (> 40 mm) collected in this
study had small intestinal diverticula. CBE staining showed a spot pattern dividing the
centre from the head to the tail septum. We observed one specimen for CBE staining
pattern: dorsomedian line small, 60 dots; dorsolateral line not observed due to dam-
age; lateral line, 42 dots; receptors on the lateral fin not found; anterolateral receptors
on the caudal fin, 2 dots; posterior receptors on the caudal fin not found.
Genus Ferosagitta Kassatkina, 1971
Diagnosis. Rigid and opaque body. Collarette present. Intestinal diverticula present.
Grasping spines not serrated. Two pairs of lateral fins completely or partially rayed.
Key to species of Ferosagitta
1 Seminal vesicles oval shaped, posterior fins with small rayless zone.... F ferox
a Seminal vesicles pear shaped, anterior and posterior fins fully rayed..............
stele Seon on telten on gn ee inten dus oe doen aya ton ele Paadven oda E robusta
Ferosagitta ferox (Doncaster, 1902)
Sagitta ferox: Doncaster, 1902: 212 p.; Fowler 1906: 10-11 p.; Michael 1919: 259-
262 p., tables 14-15; Tokioka 1959: 353-358 p., tables 1-4, figs 1-3; Alvarino
1962: 189-190 p., tables 1-5, figs 6-10; Alvarifio 1967: 66-67 p., table 11, figs
40-41; Srinivasan 1979: 13-14 p., fig. 6.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°24.504'N, 127°54.600'E), 0-50 m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, May 2019 (one specimen).
Description. Broad head. Rigid and opaque body. Collarette present. Intestinal
diverticula present. Grasping spines gently curved. Two rows of stout teeth arranged
in comb shape. Two pairs of lateral fins partially rayed, anterior fins beginning at mid-
dle of ventral ganglion. Seminal vesicles oval-shaped with an anterior protruding part
touching both lateral and caudal fins.
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of
the Pacific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the coast of Japan (Tosa
Bay) (Ohnishi et al. 2014) and the epipelagic zone (0-100 m depth) of the Korea Strait
(Park 1970). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0-100 m depth) in
Korea Strait (Fig. 1, station KS07).
Ecology. This species inhabits the surface layer of the warm water and is mainly
dominant in the Kuroshio Current of the Japanese waters (Chihara and Murano 1997).
In this study, the temperature range in the sampling locations was 25.87—28.70 °C and
the salinity range was 32.72—33.11 psu.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 193
Remarks. Only immature individual was collected in this study. We easily distin-
guished F ferox amongst the collected specimens by the presence of distinct head as
wide as the trunk and the presence of elongated ovoid seminal vesicles on the body.
The Korean specimen was classified as immature because the boundary of the seminal
vesicles was not obvious and the inside was mostly empty. This characteristic is consist-
ent with Alvarifo’s (1967) description regarding the immaturity of this species.
Ferosagitta robusta (Doncaster, 1902)
Figs 3A, 6B, 8B, 9A, 18A—-E
Sagitta robusta: Fowler, 1906: 19-20 p., figs 59-64; Ritter-Zahony 1908: 792 p.;
Burfield and Harvey 1926: 100-101 p., figs 33-37; Thomson 1947: 13-15 p.;
Alvarino 1962: 187-198 p., figs 1-5; Alvariho 1967: 66-71 p., figs 42A—D;
Srinivasan 1979: 32-34 p., fig. 18A—G.
Material examined. Yellow Sea (34°5.502'N, 124°36.000'E), 0-75 m depth, oblique
towing with conical net, Aug 2019, NIBRIV0000895305, (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged between 10.0 and 11.5 mm. Tail 27.8-
35.0% of body length. Hooks 6-8. Anterior teeth 9-10 and posterior teeth 12-20,
respectively. Rigid and opaque body (Fig. 18). Head wide as neck, roughly round
or square shaped (Fig. 18A). Grasping spines gently curved and not serrated edge of
hooks (Figs 8B, 9A). Teeth short and firm (Fig. 9A). “B” shaped eyes had “T” shaped
eye pigments (Fig. 18B). Collarette on neck (Figs 9A, 18A). Anterior fins 22.4% of
body length. Anterior fins beginning just at posterior of ventral ganglion. Starting
points of anterior fins 33.1% and ending points of anterior fins 56.5% of body length,
respectively (Fig. 18A, D). Posterior fins 25.8% of body length and 1.2 times longer
than anterior fins. Starting points of posterior fins 62.6% and ending points of pos-
terior fins 88.4% of body length, respectively. Posterior fins separated from anterior
fins and partially rayed. Caudal fin roughly round-triangle shaped, completely rayed
(Fig. 18C). Seminal vesicles pear-shaped with elongated posterior trunk and anterior
roundish knob and touching both posterior and caudal fins. (Fig. 18A, C). Conspicu-
ous intestinal diverticula present (Fig. 9A). Eggs reached anterior of ventral ganglion.
Corona ciliata beginning behind eyes and expanding to anterior of trunk (Fig. 18A).
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of Pa-
cific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the west coast of Florida (Pierce
1951), Indian coast (George 1952) and the Tosa Bay in Japan (Ohnishi et al. 2014). In
this study, specimens were found in the epipelagic zone (0—75 m depth) of the Yellow
Sea (Fig. 1: station YS03). Ferosagitta robusta is a typical Indo-pacific warm-water spe-
cies (George 1952). The horizontal distribution range is wider than the vertical range
and many individuals are mainly found in the surface layer (Park 1970). In this study,
this species rarely appeared under low temperature conditions and their presence was
predominant in the sea area affected by warm currents. The temperature range in the
sampling stations was within 25.87—28.70 °C and salinity range was 32.72—33.11 psu.
194 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Figure 18. A Ferosagitta robusta (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbreviations:
AF = anterior fin; AT = anterior teeth; CC = corona ciliata; E = eye; PF = posterior fin; PT = posterior
teeth; SV = seminal vesicle.
Remarks. Characteristics of the species in Korean waters, such as the conspicuous
intestinal diverticula, head and body width and the seminal vesicles shape, are con-
sistent with previous records (Alvarifo 1967; Chihara and Murano 1997). The main
difference between this species and another congeneric species of Korea, F ferox, is
the shape of the seminal vesicles. Seminal vesicles of F robusta are very conspicuous,
touching both posterior end of posterior fins, while that in F ferox are not so conspic-
uous and are close to both posterior fins and caudal fin (Alvarifio 1962). We observed
one specimen for CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian line, 49 dots; dorsolateral line,
38 dots; lateral line, 30 dots; receptors on the lateral fin, 6 dots; anterolateral recep-
tors on the caudal fin, 4 dots; posterior receptors on the caudal fin not observed due
to damage.
Genus Aidanosagitta Tokioka & Pathansali, 1963
Diagnosis. Rigid and opaque body. Intestinal diverticula present. Collarette present
or absent. Grasping spine gently curved and not serrated. Two rows of stout teeth ar-
ranged in a comb shape. Two pairs of lateral fins completely rayed.
Key to species of Aidanosagitta
1 Seminal vesicles large and oval shaped, well-separated from caudal fins but
LOUC HIN CIPOSLETMO MS. 045 cen dorsancosertinntonsstaniasilaletnlpseestibtesisrss A. neglecta
a Seminal Vestoteseriaa lltaineS OW CALS vicmcewsrepiedssineesinsenteopmmainsauaeddcanmsnt eres 2
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 195
2 Seminal vesicles touching both posterior fins and caudal fin and opening at
the anterolateral edge. Collarette covered on ventral ganglion (N type) from
head to body (C type) or on the partial body (I type)....... eee A. crassa
= Seminal vesicles well-separated from caudal fins, but touching the posterior
fins. Thick collarette covered head to tail. Small sized body (< 10 mm).........
Sai Madan eel he ainsee toss tok eseneaNe. ace cacoa est phy aclonetenale ME Baeanth won A. regularis
Aidanosagitta neglecta (Aida, 1897)
Sagitta neglecta: Aida, 1897: 16-17 p., fig. 7; Fowler 1906: 15-17 p., fig. 8; Michael
1919: 258 p., table 13, fig. 9; Burfield and Harvey 1926: 99 p, fig. 27; Thomson
1947: 17-18 p.; Tokioka 1959: 373-375 p., table 12, figs 103, 104; Sund 1961:
110 p., table 1; Alvarifio 1967: 74 p., table 12, figs 46, 47; Srinivasan 1979: 26-27
p. fig. 14; Nair et al. 2008: 210 p., table 2.
Material examined. Korea Strait (34°41.577'N, 127°50.460'E), 0-20 m depth,
oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2021 (one specimen).
Description. Rigid and opaque body. Narrow collarette and extending to half
distance from neck to ventral ganglion. Intestinal diverticula present. Grasping spine
gently curved. ‘Iwo rows of stout teeth arranged in comb shape. Two pairs of lateral fins
completely rayed, anterior fins beginning at end of ventral ganglion. Seminal vesicles
oval-shaped with opening at anterolateral edge, position of seminal vesicles well sepa-
rated from caudal fin, but touching posterior fins.
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0—200 m depth) of the Pacific
and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bultsand Nair 1991) andthecoastalwatersofthe Philippines, India
and Hong Kong (George 1952; Tse et al. 2007; Noblezada and Campos 2008; Lie etal. 2012).
Ecology. A mature specimen has been reported to be 8 mm is size (Alvarifio 1967).
This species shows a diurnal vertical migration in the summer off the Hong Kong coast (Lie
et al. 2012). The temperature range in the sampling stations of this study was 16.40-16.41
°C and the salinity was 34.58 psu.
Remarks. Only one immature individual was collected in this study. Aidanosagitta ne-
glecta is similar to.A. regularis in morphological characteristics including collarette. However,
the former had much larger seminal vesicles, thus they can be easily distinguished from each
other. Aidanosagitta neglecta collected from Korean waters was smaller than the previously
reported adult specimens, but seminal vesicles were obviously swollen in an oval shape.
Despite the presence of swollen seminal vesicles, the Korean specimen was considered as
immature because its size was smaller than the known record of the adult (Alvarifio 1967).
Aidanosagitta crassa (Tokioka, 1939)
Figs 3C, 5B, 19A-F
Aidanosagitta crassa £. naikaiensis: Tokioka, 1959: 376-377 p., fig. 16, table 15.
196 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Sagitta crassa: Yokioka, 1939: 349-352 p., figs 1-8
Material examined. Type C (collarette type): East Sea (37°33.198'N, 131°14.598'E),
0-100 m depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895304 (one
specimen); Yellow Sea (35°22.550'N, 126°5.366'E), 0-16.5 m depth, oblique towing
with conical net, Jul 2020, five specimens; Korea Strait (34°13.698'N, 127°35.400'E),
0-28 m depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020 (one specimen). Type N
(naked type): Yellow Sea (35°17.316'N, 126°10.483'E), 0-6.4 m depth, oblique tow-
ing with conical net, Jul 2020, NIBRIV0000895303 (three specimens).
Description. Type C: total body length ranged within 9.9 and 11.2 mm. Tail
26.6-29.8% of body length. Rigid and opaque body (Fig. 19). Head small. Collarette
beginning at neck and reaching middle of body (Fig. 19A). Round eyes star-shaped
eye pigments. Corona ciliata beginning from neck, elongated to anterior of ventral
ganglion (Fig. 19A, B). Intestinal diverticula present (Fig. 19C). Two pairs of lateral
fins completely rayed (Fig. 19E, F). Anterior fins 18.1% of body length. Anterior fins
beginning at posterior of ventral ganglion. Starting points of anterior fins 29.6% and
ending points of anterior fins 46.6% of body length, respectively (Fig. 19D). Posterior
fins 23.0% of body length and 1.3 times longer than anterior fins. Starting of posterior
fins 62.0% and ending points of posterior fins 86.9% of body length, respectively. Pos-
terior fins well separated from anterior fins beginning at middle of body (Fig. 19A, D).
Seminal vesicles longitudinally elongated (Fig. 19D). Eggs reaching posterior of ven-
tral ganglion.
Type N: total body length ranged between 8.1 and8.2 mm. Tail 27.0-30.0% of body
length (Fig. 19B). Collarette beginning at anterior of ventral ganglion and reaching pos-
terior of ventral ganglion (Fig. 19B). Anterior fins 19.1% of body length. Anterior fins
beginning at posterior of ventral ganglion. Starting points of anterior fins 34.0% and end
points of anterior fins 54.6% of body length, respectively (Fig. 19B). Posterior fins 24.6%
of body length and 1.3 times longer than anterior fins. Starting points of posterior head
60.9% and ending points of posterior fins 88.2% of body length, respectively. Posterior
fins well-separated from anterior fins beginning at middle of body (Fig. 19A, B).
Distribution. This species is found in the neritic water of the Pacific Ocean
(Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991), the neritic coastal water of Hong Kong (Tse et al. 2007)
and the Tosa Bay of Japan (Ohnishi et al. 2014). In this study, it was found in the
epipelagic zone (0-100 m depth) of the East Sea, Korea Strait and Yellow Sea (Fig. 1,
stations ESO1, YSO1, YSO2 and KSO1).
Ecology. Aidanosagitta crassa appears in high abundance throughout the year in
the relatively low saline waters of the Yellow Sea and coast of Jeju (Park 1970). This
species rarely appears in the summer warm waters of southern Korea. The body length
varies according to the season and it has been reported that they are large (type C)
in winter and small in summer (type N) (Park 1970). Specimens of type C die after
spawning and those of type N dominate the new generation (Park 1970). We obtained
specimens from the East Sea in winter and the Yellow Sea in summer.
Remarks. Previous researchers classified Aidanosagitta crassa into three types accord-
ing to the distribution of the collarette: C type, covers from the neck to the body; N type,
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 197
Figure 19. A Aidanosagitta crassa Type C (dorsal view) B Aidanosagitta crassa Type N (dorsal view) C head
and neck D tail E anterior fin F posterior fin. Abbreviations: AF = anterior fin; CC = corona ciliata;
COL = collarette; E = eye; IN = intestine; ID = intestine diverticula; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
covers only the ventral ganglion; and I type, covers the ventral ganglion and partially cov-
ers the body (Park 1970). In this study, specimens of types C and N were collected and
the Korean type C from the Yellow Sea had the same morphological characteristics of
the collarette as the original description of this species reported by Tokioka (1939). Simi-
larly, type N, which appeared together with type C at other stations of the Yellow Sea,
was consistent with the morphological characteristics of the collarette of A. crassa and f
naikaiensis (Tokioka 1939). It has been reported that the three types of A. crassa appear
at different periods depending on environmental factors (water temperature and salinity)
of the specific sea area; however, in this study, both types appeared simultaneously in the
Yellow Sea. A more detailed ecological investigation of the impact of environment factors
on the succession of the three types of A. crassa is necessary. We observed four specimens
for type C of A. crassa CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian line, 14 dots; dorsolateral
line, > 100 dots; lateral line, 8 dots; receptors on the lateral fin, 8 dots; anterolateral
receptors on the caudal fin, 4 dots; posterior receptors on the caudal fin, 6 dots. The pat-
tern of dorsomedian dots was small spots that crossed the centre of the body and larger
symmetrical spots on dorsolateral line dots. In addition, we observed three specimens for
type N of A. crassa CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian line, 35 dots; dorsolateral line, 34
dots; lateral line, 12 dots; receptors on the lateral fin, not observed; anterolateral recep-
tors on the caudal fin, 2 dots; posterior receptors on the caudal fin, 4 dots.
198 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Aidanosagitta regularis (Aida, 1897)
Figs 6A, 7A, 10A, 20A-E
Sagitta regularis: Aida, 1897: 17-18 p., fig. 8; Doncaster 1902: 211 p., fig. 7; Burfield and
Harvey 1926: 100 p., figs 31-32; Thomson 1947: 18-19 p.; Alvarifio 1967: 72-75 p.,
fig. 48A—D; Srinivasan 1979: 31-32 p., fig. 17A—F; Nair et al. 2008: 110 p., table 2.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°33.600'N, 127°34.002'E), 0-96 m depth,
oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895302 (one specimen);
northern East China Sea (32°33.000'N, 126°30.000'E), 0-100 m depth, oblique tow-
ing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895301 (one specimen); northern East
China Sea (32°30.000'N, 127°5.100'E), 0-120 m depth, oblique towing with conical
net, Feb 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged within 6.1 and 6.7 mm. Tail 30.5—31.7% of
body length. Hooks 6. Anterior teeth 3—4 and posterior teeth 5—6, respectively. Rigid
and opaque body (Fig. 20). Head small, triangular shaped (Fig. 20B). Round eyes with
“B”-shaped eye pigments (Fig. 20B). Collarette expanding to seminal vesicles (Fig. 20A).
Corona ciliata beginning from neck to anterior of ventral ganglion (Fig. 10A). Anterior
fins 12.3% of body length. Anterior fins beginning at posterior of ventral ganglion.
Starting points of anterior fins 37.3% and ending points of anterior fins 50.9% of
body length, respectively (Fig. 20D). Posterior fins 22.0% of body length and 1.8 times
longer than anterior fins. Starting points of posterior fins 62.9% and ending points of
posterior fins 84.7% of body length, respectively. Posterior fins not connected to ante-
rior fins, beginning in front of caudal septum and both anterior fins and posterior fins
completely rayed (Fig. 20D, E). Caudal fin fully rayed and roughly round or triangle-
shaped (Fig. 20C). Intestinal diverticula present (Figs 7A, 20B). Seminal vesicles longi-
tudinally elongated along body (Fig. 20C). Eggs reaching posterior of ventral ganglion.
Distribution. ‘This species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth) and mesope-
lagic zones (200-500 m depth) of Pacific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair
1991) and the epipelagic zone (0—100 m depth) of the Tosa Bay in Japan (Ohnishi et al.
2014). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0-120 m depth) of the Korea
Strait and northern East China Sea (Fig. 1, stations KS06, nECSO1 and nECS02).
Ecology. This species is considered a warm-water Indo-Pacific indicator species
because many individuals appear in high-temperature and high-salinity water and the
distribution range is limited to the areas affected by warm currents (Park 1970).
Remarks. Amongst the Korean specimens, the collarette was differently inflated,
thick and covered the body surface. However, the position and shape of the corona
ciliata and fins were consistent with the original description (Aida 1897). Aidanosag-
itta regularis is similar to A. bedfordii; however, these two species can be distinguished
by the morphological difference in the eye pigments (elongated vs. roundish). We ob-
served two specimens for CBE staining pattern: dorsomedian line, 28 dots; dorsolat-
eral line, 34 dots; lateral line, 44 dots; receptors on the lateral fin, 3 dots; anterolateral
receptors on the caudal fin, 2 dots; posterior receptors on the caudal fin, not observed
due to damage.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 199
Figure 20. A Aidanosagitta regularis (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbrevia-
tions: CC = corona ciliata; COL = collarette; E = eye; SV = seminal vesicle.
Genus Sagitta Quoy & Gaimard, 1827
Diagnosis. Rigid and opaque body. Collarette almost absent. Intestinal diverticula ab-
sent or present. Grasping spines not serrated. Iwo pairs of lateral fins completely rayed.
Sagitta bipunctata Quoy & Gaimard, 1827
Sagitta bipunctata: Quoy & Gaimard, 1827: 232-233 p., figs 1, 2, 6, 7; Aida 1897:
13-14 p., fig. 1; Ritter-Zahony 1908: 15 p., figs 2, 2A; Ritter-Zahony 1910: 2
p.. Fowler 1906: 68 p.; Sund 1961: 110 p., table 1; Alvarifo 1967: 44-49 p.,
fig. 26A—D; Dallot and Ducret 1969: 19 p., table 1; Srinivasan 1979: 8-9 p., fig.
3A-F; Michel 1984: 17-18 p., fig. 18; McLelland 1989: 163-164 p., figs 9A, 12];
Villenas and Palma 2006: 105 p., table 1
Material examined. Yellow sea (33°0.111'N, 125°29.581'E), 0 — 86 m depth, oblique
towing, July 2020.
Description. Small, rigid and opaque body. Small head. Collarette almost absent
(thin on neck). Eyes square-shaped with no eye pigments observed in this study. Intesti-
nal diverticula absent. Forward end of anterior fins not visible. Posterior fins beginning
in front of caudal septum and closing to seminal vesicles, completely rayed. Seminal
vesicles elongated with small indentations and touching both lateral and caudal fins.
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic (0-200 m depth) and
mesopelagic zones (200-500 m depth) of Pacific, Indian and Atlantic Oceans
(Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991). This species appears in most of the seas across Ko-
rean waters.
200 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Ecology. Sagitta bipunctata is known as a cosmopolitan species, appearing in tem-
perate and tropical seas; it is an indicator species of high salinity and the presence of
oceanic water (Pierce 1953). The temperature range in sampling stations of this study
was 15.08—22.17 °C and the salinity range was 31.77—34.01 psu.
Remarks. Only one immature individual was collected in this study. Sag-
itta bipunctata can be distinguished from other Korean species by the following
characteristics: absence of intestinal diverticular, presence of completely rayed lateral
fins and the restricted position of collarette on the posterior part of the body. The
seminal vesicles of Korean specimen were not sufficiently mature compared to the
description of Alvarifio (1967).
Zonosagitta Tokioka, 1965a
Diagnosis. Rigid or flaccid and transparent or opaque body. Collarette small (almost
absent). Intestinal diverticula absent. Grasping spines not serrated. Two pairs of lateral
fins partially rayed. Anterior part of anterior fins elongated and rayless. Anterior fins
longer than posterior fins.
Key to species of Zonosagitta
1 The anterior fins beginning at the middle of ventral ganglion, the seminal
vesicles oval shaped touching neither the posterior fins nor caudal fin, small
eyes with star-shaped /-€ye PiGMisnits: .....0...essencerrsancossssnserssncsaresseesss Z. bedoti
= The anterior fins beginning at the end of ventral ganglion, the seminal vesicles
conical-shaped and touching both lateral fins and caudal fin, small eyes with
TE RESHAPEC CVC NOLS MICS TS thesia adr. uucienahiveu nine unnadasMisomininevle Z. nagae
“ The anterior fins beginning at the middle of ventral ganglion, the seminal
vesicles elongated with a roundish anterior protruding part, small eyes with
Stan shapedreye PIGMENTS: eaalvesqtsanenssahanetauvst dans Aeaer eeaadeas Z. pulchra
Zonosagitta bedoti (Béraneck, 1895)
Figs 7D, 21A-E
Sagitta bedoti f. minor: Tokioka, 1959: 89-90 p., table 18.
Sagitta bedoti: Béraneck, 1895: 147-152 p.; Fowler 1906: 6-8 p., figs 1-8; Michael
1919: 255-257 p., figs 6, 20, 24, 30; Burfield and Harvey 1926: 94—95p., figs
1-2; Thomson 1947: 18 p.; Kitou 1966: 239 p., table 1; Alvarifo 1967: 53-55
p., fig. 32A—D; Francisco 1977: 229-231 p., plate 2; Srinivasan 1979: 6-7 p.,
fig. 2A-G.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°0.000'N, 125°18.000'E), 0-75 m depth, oblique
towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895300 (one specimen); northern
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 201
5000 pm
Figure 21. A Zonosagitta bedoti (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbreviations:
AF = anterior fin; E = eye; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
East China Sea (31°30.000'N, 126°28.998'E), 0-82 m depth, oblique towing with
conical net, Feb 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged from 16-17 mm. Tail 3.71% of body
length. Hooks 7. Anterior teeth 27—28 and posterior teeth 30-35, respectively.
Opaque and rigid body (Fig. 21). Head wider than body (Figs 7D, 21A). Short
and dense teeth. Intestinal diverticula absent (Figs 7D, 21B). “D”-shaped eyes
with star-shaped eye pigments (Fig. 21B). Corona ciliata beginning behind eyes
and elongated over neck (Fig. 21B). Anterior fins 26.5% of body length. Ante-
rior fins beginning at middle of ventral ganglion, anterior of anterior fins narrow
with rayless zone and posterior of anterior fins partially rayed. Anterior fins 1.3
times longer than posterior fins. Starting points of anterior fins 34.3% and ending
points of anterior fins 60.0% of body length, respectively (Fig. 21A, D). Posterior
fins 19.8% of body LENGTH. Starting points of posterior fins 63.7% and ending
points of posterior fins 89.7% of body length, respectively. Posterior fins con-
nected with anterior fins (Fig. 21A). Caudal fin triangular-shaped and completely
rayed (Fig. 21C). Seminal vesicles spherical in shape with lateral rupture in mature
specimen (Fig. 21C).
Distribution. ‘This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of the
Pacific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991) and the Tosa Bay in Japan
(Ohnishi et al. 2014). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone (0-100 m depth)
of the Korea Strait and northern East China Sea (Fig. 1: stations KSO9 and nECS06).
Ecology. Zonosagitta bedoti is used as an indicator species in the front area where warm
and cold water meet (Park 1970). The temperature range in the sampling location in this
study was between 14.62 and 15.01 °C and the salinity range was 33.67—33.81 psu.
Remarks. Zonosagitta bedoti and Z. nagae are similar in morphology at the im-
mature stage. However, because adult Z. nagae are relatively larger, immature Z. nagae
202 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
may be misidentified as Z. bedoti. Adults of both species can be distinguished from
each other by the shape of seminal vesicles and eye pigments. Zonosagitta nagae has
an “E”-shaped eye pigment, while Z. bedoti has a star-shaped eye pigment. The spot
pattern on the body surface found through CBE staining is as follows: irregular spot
pattern which continued from the head to the ventral ganglion and six spots along the
outside of the body were symmetrical around the tail.
Zonosagitta nagae (Alvarifio, 1967)
Figs GD, 7C, 22A-E
Sagitta nagae: Alvarifho, 1967: 55—58 p., fig. 34A—D.
Material examined. Korea Strait (33°29.662'N, 125°30.881'E), oblique towing with
MOCNESS, 32-58 m depth, July 2020, NIBRIV0000895297 (two specimens); Korea
Strait (33°24.504'N, 127°54.600'E), 0-50 m depth, oblique towing with conical net,
May 2019, two specimens; northern East China Sea (31°30.000'N, 125°17.100'E),
0-50 m depth, oblique towing with conical net, Feb 2020, NIBRIV0000895296
(one specimen).
Description. Total body length ranged from 11-15 mm. Hooks 6-8. Ante-
rior teeth 11-15 and posterior teeth 15-35, respectively. Rigid and opaque body
(Fig. 22A). Long and dense teeth. Collarette present on neck (Fig. 22B). Intestinal di-
verticula absent (Fig. 7C). Eyes “D”-shaped with “E”-shaped eye pigments (Fig. 22B).
Anterior fins 27.7% of body length and 1.5 times longer than posterior fins. Anterior
fins beginning in front of ventral ganglion and partially rayed. Starting points of ante-
rior fins 28.6% and ending points of anterior fins 59.8% of body length, respectively
(Fig. 22A, D). Posterior fins 18.0% of body length. Starting points of posterior fins
67.8% and ending points of posterior fins 91.9% of body length, respectively. Pos-
terior fins connecting with anterior fins partially rayed (Fig. 22A, E). Seminal ves-
icles conical-shaped with small indentations and well separated from posterior fins
(Fig. 22C). Eggs reached posterior of anterior fins. Corona ciliata beginning behind
eyes and elongated over neck (Fig. 22C).
Distribution. This species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of the
Pacific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991). In this study, the species was
found in the epipelagic zone (0-120 m depth) of the northern East China Sea, the
Korea Strait and the Yellow Sea (Fig. 1: stations KS03, KSO7 and nECS05).
Ecology. This species appears year-round in most of the seas around Korea, pre-
dominantly in the southern and western seas and shows high abundance in areas where
warm and cold currents meet (Park 1970). In summer, the temperature range was
15.49-28.70 °C and the salinity was 30.92—34.01 psu. In winter, the temperature
range was 11.47—11.58 °C and the salinity was 32.44—32.49 psu.
Remarks. ‘The anterior fin of Zonosagitta nagae had a longer rayless zone than the
posterior fin, clearly distinguishing it from Z. bedoti. CBE staining showed the follow-
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 203
250 pm
Figure 22. A Zonosagitta nagae (dorsal view) B head C tail D anterior fin E posterior fin. Abbreviations:
AF = anterior fin; E = eye; PF = posterior fin; SV = seminal vesicle.
ing spot pattern on the body surface: an irregular spot pattern continued from the head
to the middle of the ventral ganglion; symmetrical dots appeared near the rayless zone
of each fin (13 spots on anterior fin, 6 spots on posterior fin).
Zonosagitta pulchra (Doncaster, 1902)
Sagitta pulchra: Doncaster, 1902: 213 p.; Fowler 1906: 72 p.; Michael 1919: 251-253
p., tables 7, 8; Burfield and Harvey 1926: 100 p., fig. 30; Thomson 1947: 19-20
p.s Kitou 1966: 239 p., table 1; Alvarifo 1967: 34-35 p., figs 20-21; Francisco
1977: 231-233 p.; Srinivasan 1979: 29-30 p., fig. 16.
Material examined. Korea Strait (34°17.868'N, 128°15.854'E), 0-GO m depth,
oblique towing with MOCNESS, Feb 2020 (one specimen).
Description. Rigid and transparent body. Collarette present. Intestinal diverticula
absent. Grasping spine gently curved. Two rows of stout teeth arranged in comb shape.
Two pairs of lateral fins partially rayed, anterior fins begin at the end of ventral gangli-
on. Seminal vesicles elongated with an anterior protruding part usually roughly round
and touching both lateral fins and caudal fin.
Distribution. ‘The species is found in the epipelagic zone (0-200 m depth) of the
Pacific and Indian Oceans (Pierrot-Bults and Nair 1991) and off the coast of Philip-
pines (Noblezada and Campos 2008). In this study, it was found in the epipelagic zone
(0-120 m depth) of the northern East China Sea, the Korea Strait and the Yellow Sea
(Fig. 1: station KS02).
204 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Ecology. Z. pulchra is considered to be a neritic species (Bieri 1959; Pierrot-Bults
and van der Spoel 2003). The temperature range in the sampling stations of this study
was 11.95-14.79 °C and the salinity range was 33.59-34.00 psu.
Remarks. Only one immature individual was collected in this study. The examined
Korean specimen belongs to the genus Zonosagitta by the absence of intestinal
diverticular and the presence of rayless zone in the anterior part of anterior fins. ‘This
Korean specimen was identified as Z. pulchra because its anterior fins were more angled
than those of Z. bedoti or Z. nagae. The seminal vesicles of Korean specimen were not
sufficiently mature compared to description of Alvarifo (1967).
Discussion
Based on a taxonomic review of newly obtained specimens from Korea, we confirmed
the appearance of chaetognath taxa in Korean waters corresponding to one order,
three families, 11 genera and 18 species. Taxonomically identified voucher specimens
(Krohnitta subtilis, K. pacifica, Pterosagitta draco, Aidanosagitta crassa, A. neglecta,
A. regularis, Ferosagitta ferox, F. robusta, Flaccisagitta enflata, F hexaptera, Mesosagitta
minima, Parasagitta elegans, Pseudosagitta lyra, Sagitta bipunctata, Serratosagitta pacifi-
ca, Zonosagitta bedoti, Z. nagae and Z. pulchra) were obtained for the first time in Korea
and their taxonomic and ecological features were reported. Although the overall mor-
phological characteristics of the six species (A. neglecta, F. ferox, K. pacifica, M. minima,
S. bipunctata and Z. pulchra) were mostly consistent with the previously-reported spe-
cies, their essential characteristics have been briefly described in this study because
only immature individuals of these six species were collected. On the contrary, the
three species (Decipisagitta decipiens, Serratosagitta serratodentata, S. pseudoserratoden-
tata) mentioned in literature have very poor taxonomic basis for their academic report
(drawings, descriptions and voucher specimens), which can result in possible misiden-
tification and their presence in Korean waters is questionable. Most of the samples in
this study were collected in summer and winter. Extension of the investigation period
to spring and autumn in future studies can facilitate identification of adult specimens
of the above-mentioned six species or clarification of the presence or absence of the
three suspicious species.
The detailed characteristics of the corona ciliata and fins of chaetognaths are
important as taxonomic keys to distinguish genera, but they are difficult to observe
under a stereomicroscope. In order to address this problem, we stained the surface
of the specimens with CBE, which has rarely been used in the past for observing
chaetognaths. The CBE staining of the Korean specimens clearly revealed the fea-
tures of the corona ciliata, fins and body surface. The corona ciliata of Aidanosag-
itta is located from behind the eyes to the anterior part of the trunk, whereas that
of Sagitta, Serratosagitta, Ferosagitta, Parasagitta and Zonosagitta extends from the
front of the eyes to the neck; hence, the two groups could be clearly distinguished.
Flaccisagitta is also distinctly differentiable from other genera as the corona ciliata
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 205
extends from the front of the eyes to the anterior part of the neck. We propose
the location and shape of these corona ciliata as additional taxonomic keys to
distinguish Korean taxa at the genus level. On the contrary, Krohnitta subtilis had
a circular corona ciliata located in front of the eyes, unlike other congeneric spe-
cies, in which a circular corona ciliata appeared behind the eyes. Bieri (1974) has
suggested the artificial position change of the corona ciliata due to damaged speci-
mens. Therefore, the differences in corona ciliata between Krohnitta subtilis found
in Korea and other known congeneric species need to be confirmed by examining
more specimens.
The distribution of dots on the body surface was easily confirmed through mi-
croscopic observation after CBE staining. The dots pattern is expressed by a regular
arrangement of tactile cilia distributed on the body surface of the chaetognaths (Aida
1897). The tactile cilia are reported to have two types of hair (Aida 1897; Feigen-
baum 1978). One is transversally orientated ciliary fence organs and the other is
longitudinally orientated ciliary tuft organs (Aida 1897; Bone and Pulsford 1978;
Miller et al. 2014). The tactile cilia are capable of responding to water movement on
the surface of the body or of detecting prey (Horridge and Boulton 1967). Recent
studies have established the role of tactile cilia as nerve receptors (Miller et al. 2014).
In this study, Aidanosagitta, Serratosagitta and Ferosagitta have similar round dots of
symmetry based on the dorsal median line from the head to the tail, but their size
and location are different for each genus. Zonosagitta nagae and Z. bedoti also showed
a marked difference from other genera by showing irregular spot patterns from the
head to the ventral ganglion.
On the contrary, Flaccisagitta did not have similar spot patterns on the body sur-
face between the two Korean species. Irregular spots on the body surface of the Flac-
cisagitta enflata were observed; however, F hexaptera did not exhibit any spot patterns,
similar to Pseudosagitta lyra. Since the fully-grown body of this species is usually large
with a size of 50 mm and more, it is presumed that the relatively thick epidermis
prevented effective staining. The regularity of these patterns has also been observed in
species such as Sagitta hispida, S. enflata, S. elegans, Spadella schizoptera and Spadella
cephaloptera (Feigenbaum, 1977); however, evidence for establishing a connection with
genealogy is lacking. Moreover, basic data obtained from a complete individual pattern
will be valuable to explain the commonalities at genus levels. Further application of
the CBE staining method to other taxa of Aphragmophora will clarify whether new
features, such as the location and shape of the corona ciliata and the spot patterns on
the body surface, are effective as genus or species grouping features.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Dr. Kasatkina, Dr. Perez and Dr. P Stoev who made construc-
tive and invaluable suggestions and comments. This work was supported by a grant
from the National Institute of Biological Resources (NIBR), funded by the Ministry of
206 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Environment (MOE) of the Republic of Korea (NIBR202130203) and project titled
“Research center for fishery resource management based on the information and com-
munication technology” (2022, Grant number 20180384), funded by the Ministry of
Oceans and Fisheries, Korea.
References
Aida T (1897) Chaetognaths of Misaki Harbor. Annotationes Zoologicae Japonenses 1: 13-21.
Alvarifio A (1961) Two new chaetognaths from the Pacific. Pacific Science 15(1): 67-77.
Alvariio A (1962) Taxonomic revision of Sagitta robusta and Sagitta ferox Doncaster, and notes
on their distribution in the Pacific. Pacific Science 16: 186-201.
Alvariio A (1967) The Chaetognatha of the NAGA Expedition (1959-1961): In the South
China Sea and the Gulf of Thailand (Vol. 4). University of California, Scripps Institution
of Oceanography, 197 pp.
Beraneck E (1895) Les chétognathes de la baie d’ Amboine (voyage de MM. M. Bedot et C.
Pictet dans l’archipel Malais). Revue Suisse de Zoologie et Annales du Musée d'Histoire
naturelle de Genéve 3: 137-159. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl. part.75 137
Bieri R (1959) The Distribution of the Planktonic Chaetognatha in the Pacific and their Re-
lationship to the Water Masses 1. Limnology and Oceanography 4(1): 1-28. https://doi.
org/10.4319/lo.1959.4.1.0001
Bieri R (1974) A new species of Spadella (Chaetognatha) from California. Publica-
tions of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory 21(3-4): 281-286. https://doi.
org/10.5134/175863
Bieri R (1991) Systematics of the Chaetognatha. In: Bone Q, Kapp H, Pierrot-Bults AC (Eds)
The Biology of the Chaetognaths. Oxford Science Publications, New York, 122-136.
Bleich S, Miiller CH, Graf G, Hanke W (2017) Flow generation by the corona ciliata in Chae-
tognatha — quantification and implications for current functional hypotheses. Zoology
(Jena, Germany) 125: 79-86. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.zool.2017.09.001
Bone Q, Pulsford A (1978) The arrangement of ciliated sensory cells in Spadella (Chaetogna-
tha). Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 58(3): 565-570.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0025315400041229
Bone Q, Pulsford A (1984) The sense organs and ventral ganglion of Sagitta (Chaetognatha).
Acta Zoologica 65(4): 209-220. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1463-6395.1984.tb01042.x
Bone Q, Kapp H, Pierrot-Bults AC (1991) Biology of chaetognaths. Distribution patterns in
chaetognatha. In: Bone Q, Kapp H, Pierrot-Bults AC (Eds) The Biology of the Chaetog-
naths. Oxford Science Publications, New York, 86-116.
Burfield ST, Harvey EJW (1926) No. V.-The Chetognatha of the “Sealark” Expedition. Trans-
actions of the Linnean Society of London. 2 Series. Zoology (Jena, Germany) 19(1):
93-119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1096-3642.1926.tb00543.x
Chacko PI (1949) Food and feeding habits of the fishes of the Gulf of Manaar. Proceedings
of the Indiana Academy of Sciences 29(3): 83-97. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03049962
Chihara M, Murano M (1997) An Illustrated Guide to Marine Plankton in Japan. Tokai Uni-
versity Press, 1571 pp.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 207
Choe N, Deibel D (2000) Seasonal vertical distribution and population dynamics of the
chaetognath Parasagitta elegans in the water column and hyperbenthic zone of Concep-
tion Bay, Newfoundland. Marine Biology 137(5): 847-856. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s002270000413
Claus C, Grobben K (1905) Lehrbuch der Zoologie. Elwertsche Verlagsbuchhandlung,
Marburg, Hessen, 955 pp.
Conant FS (1896) XXXII. — Notes on the Choetognaths. Journal of Natural History 18(105):
201-214. https://doi.org/10.1080/00222939608680443
Costa A (1869) Di un nuovo genere di Chetognati. Annuario del Museo Zoologico della Uni-
versita di Napoli 5: e54.
Dallot S, Ducret F (1969) Un chaetognathe mésoplanctonique nouveau: Sagitta megaloph-
thalma sp. n. Beaufortia 17(224): 13-20.
Doncaster L (1902) Chaetognatha, with a note on the variation and distribution of the group.
The fauna and geography of the Maldive and Laccadive Archipelagoes 1: 209-218.
Ducret F (1974) Sur un chaetognathe voisin de Sagitta tropica observe en Mer Rouge. Journal
of the Marine Biological Association of India 16: 161-168.
Duvert M, Salat C (1990) Ultrastructural studies on the fins of chaetognaths. Tissue & Cell
22(6): 853-863. https://doi.org/10.1016/0040-8166(90)90048-E
Feigenbaum DL (1978) Hair-fan patterns in the Chaetognatha. Canadian Journal of Zoology
56(4): 536-546. https://doi.org/10.1139/z78-077
Fowler GH (1906) The Chaetognatha of the Siboga Expedition. Siboga-Esped., Mon. xxi.
1907. Chaetognatha. National Antarctic Expedition Natural History 3: 991-996.
Francisco PP (1977) Taxonomy of the chaetognaths of the bight of panama. Anales del Insti-
tuto de Investigaciones Marinas de Punta Betin 9: 225-240.
Gasmi S, Néve G, Pech N, Tekaya S, Gilles A, Perez Y (2014) Evolutionary history of Chae-
tognatha inferred from molecular and morphological data: A case study for body plan
simplification. Frontiers in Zoology 11(1): 1-25. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12983-014-
0084-7
George PC (1952) A systematic account of the chaetognatha of the Indian coastal waters, with
observations on their seasonal fluctuations along the Malabar Coast. Proceedings of the
National Institute of Sciences of India 18(6): 657-689.
Germain L, Joubin L (1912) Note sur quelques Chétognathes nouveaux des croisiéres de SAS
le Prince de Monaco. Bulletin de l'Institut Océanographique 228: 1-14.
Grassi BC (1883) I Chetognati. Fauna und Flora des Golfes von Neapel Monograph 5: 1-126.
Grigor JJ, Schmid MS, Caouette M, Onge VS, Brown TA, Barthélemy RM (2020) Non-car-
nivorous feeding in Arctic chaetognaths. Progress in Oceanography 186: e102388. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.pocean.2020.102388
Horridge GA, Boulton PS (1967) Prey detection by Chaetognatha via a vibration sense. Pro-
ceedings of the Royal Society of London: Series B, Biological Sciences 168(1013): 413-
419. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.1967.0072
Hyman L (1959) The enterocoelous coelomates-phylum Chaetognatha. The invertebrates:
smaller coelomate groups 5: 1-71.
Kapp H (1991) Morphology and anatomy. In: Bone Q, Kapp H, Pierrot-Bults AC (Eds) The
Biology of the Chaetognaths. Oxford Science Publications, New York, 5-17.
208 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Kassatkina AP (1971) New neritic species of chaetognaths from the Possjet Bay in the Sea of
Japan. Zoological Institute Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R 8(16): 265-294.
Kim WR (1987) Taxonomical study on the chaetognaths in Korean waters. Master ‘Thesis,
University of Hanyang, Seoul, South Korea.
Kitou M (1966) A new species of Sagitta (Chaetognatha) collected off the Izu Peninsula. La
mer: Bulletin de la Société franco-japonaise d’Océanographie 4: 238-240.
Krohn A (1844) Anatomisch physiologische Beobachtungen uber die Sagitta bipunctata. Nes-
tler and Melle, Hamburg, Germany, 16 pp. https://doi.org/10.1080/037454809496523
Krohn A (1853) Nachtragliche Bemerkungen tiber den Bau der Gattung Sagitta, nebst der
Beschreibung einiger neuen Arten. Archiv fiir Naturgeschichte 19: 266-281.
Kruse S, Brey T, Bathmann U (2010) Role of midwater chaetognaths in Southern Ocean pe-
lagic energy flow. Marine Ecology Progress Series 416: 105-113. https://doi.org/10.3354/
meps08773
Lea HE (1955) The chaetognaths of western Canadian coastal waters. Journal of the Fisheries
Board of Canada 12(4): 593-617. https://doi.org/10.1139/f55-031
Lee BR, Kim HW, Park W (2016) Distribution of chaetognaths (Aphragmophora: Sagitti-
dae) in Korean waters. Ocean Science Journal 51(3): 447-454. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s12601-016-0040-x
Liang TH, Vega-Pérez LA (1995) Studies on chaetognaths off Ubatuba region, Brazil. II. Feed-
ing habits. Boletim do Instituto Oceanografico 43(1): 35-48. https://doi.org/10.1590/
S0373-55241995000100003
Lie AA, Tse P, Wong CK (2012) Diel vertical migration and feeding of three species of chae-
tognaths (Flaccisagitta enflata, Aidanosagitta delicata and Aidanosagitta neglecta) in two
shallow, subtropical bays in Hong Kong. Journal of Plankton Research 34(8): 670-684.
https://doi.org/10.1093/plankt/fbs041
Lutschinger S (1993) The marine fauna of New Zealand: Chaetognatha (arrow worms). New
Zealand Oceanographic Institute Memoir 101.
McLelland JA (1989) An illustrated key to the Chaetognatha of the northern Gulf of Mexico
with notes on their distribution. Gulf and Caribbean Research 8(2): 145-172. https://doi.
org/10.18785/grr.0802.07
Michael E (1908) Notes on the Identification of the Chaetognatha. The Biological Bulletin
15(2): 67-84. https://doi.org/10.2307/1536091
Michael E (1919) Report on the Chaetognatha collected by the United States fisheries steamer
“Albatross” during the Philippine expedition, 1907-1910 (Vol. 1). Bulletin - United States
National Museum 1(4): 235-277. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl. title. 17878
Michel HB (1984) Chaetognatha of the Caribbean Sea and adjacent areas (Vol. 15). National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Technical Report of National Marine Fisheries
Service 15::€25.
Molchanov LA (1907) Ein Beitrag zur Klassification der Chaetognathen. Zoologischer Anzeiger
Leipzig 31: 220-222.
Miller CH, Rieger V, Perez Y, Harzsch S (2014) Immunohistochemical and ultrastructural
studies on ciliary sense organs of arrow worms (Chaetognatha). Zoomorphology 133(2):
167-189. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00435-013-0211-6
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 209
Miller CH, Harzsch S, Perez Y (2019) 7. Chaetognatha (Handbook of Zoology). Miscellaneous
Invertebrates, De Gruyter, Germany, 282 pp. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110489279-
007
Nagai N, Tadokoro K, Kuroda K, Sugimoto T (2006) Occurrence characteristics of chaetog-
nath species along the PM transect in the Japan Sea during 1972—2002. Journal of Ocean-
ography 62(5): 597-606. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10872-006-0079-x
Nagasawa S (1976) Identification of young chaetognaths based on the characteristics of eyes
and pigmented regions. Bulletin of the Plankton Society of Japan 23: 96-106.
Nagasawa S, Marumo R (1972) Feeding of a pelagic chaetognath, Sagitta nagae Alvarifo in Su-
ruga Bay, central Japan. Journal of the Oceanographical Society of Japan 28(5): 181-186.
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02108551
Nair VR, Panampunnayil SU, Pillai HU, Gireesh R (2008) Two new species of Chaetognatha
from the Andaman Sea, Indian Ocean. Marine Biology Research 4(3): 208-214. https://
doi.org/10.1080/17451000701696260
Nair VR, Kidangan FX, Prabhu RG, Bucklin A, Nair S (2015) DNA barcode of Chaetognatha
from Indian Waters. Indian journal of Geo-Marine Science 44(9): 1366-1376.
Noblezada MMP, Campos WL (2008) Spatial distribution of chaetognaths off the northern
Bicol Shelf, Philippines (Pacific coast). ICES Journal of Marine Science 65(3): 484-494.
https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsn027
Ohnishi T, Ueda H, Kuroda K (2014) Community structure and spatial distribution of chae-
tognaths in Tosa Bay on the temperate Kuroshio coast of Japan. Plankton & Benthos
Research 9(3): 176-187. https://doi.org/10.3800/pbr.9.176
Park JS (1967) Note Sur Les Chaetognathes Indicateurs Planctoniques Dans La Mer Coreenne
En Hiver 1967. The Korean Society of Oceanography 2(1—2): 34-41.
Park JS (1970) The chaetognaths of Korean waters. PhD Thesis, Pukyong National University,
Busan, South Korea.
Park JS (1973) The distribution of chaetognaths in the Korea strait and their relation to the
character of water masses. The Korean Society of Oceanography 8(1): 22-32.
Park JS, Lee SS, Kang YS, Lee BD, Hun SH (1990) The distributions of copepods and chaetog-
naths in the southern waters of Korea and their relationship to the characteristics of water
masses. Korean Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 23(3): 245-252.
Park JS, Lee SS, Kang YS, Huh SH (1991) Distribution of indicator species of copepods and
chaetognaths in the middle East Sea of Korea and their relationships to the characteristics
of water masses. Korean Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 24(3): 203-213.
Park JS, Lee SS, Kang YS, Lee BD, Huh SH (1992) Distribution of indicator species of cope-
pods and chaetognaths in the southeastern area of the Yellow Sea and their relationship to
the characteristics of water masses. Korean Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 25 (4):
251-264.
Peter S, Nair MB, Pillai D (2020) Evolutionary analyses of phylum Chaetognatha based on
mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I gene. Turkish Journal of Zoology 44(6): 508-518.
https://doi.org/10.3906/zoo-2004-18
Pierce EL (1951) The Chaetognatha of the west coast of Florida. The Biological Bulletin 100(3):
206-228. https://doi.org/10.2307/1538532
210 Seohwi Choo et al. / ZooKeys 1106: 165-211 (2022)
Pierrot-Bults AC (1974) Taxonomy and zoogeography of certain members of the “Sagitta ser-
ratodentata-group” (Chaetognatha). Bijdragen tot de Dierkunde 44(2): 215-234. https://
doi.org/10.1163/26660644-04402002
Pierrot-Bults AC (1976) Histology of the seminal vesicles in the “Sagitta serratodentata-group”
(Chaetognatha). Bulletin Zoologisch Museum 5(4): 19-30.
Pierrot-Bults AC, Nair VR (1991) Distribution patterns in Chaetognatha. In: Bone Q, Kapp
H, Pierrot-Bults AC (Eds) The Biology of the Chaetognaths. Oxford Science Publications,
New York, 86-116.
Pierrot-Bults AC, van der Spoel S (2003) Macro zooplankton diversity: How much do we really
know? Zodlogische Verhandelingen 345: 297-312.
Prado MS (1961) Chaetognatha encontrados em aguas brasileiras. Boletim do Instituto Ocean-
ografico 11(2): 31-55. https://doi.org/10.1590/S0373-55241961000100002
Quoy JRC, Gaimard JP (1827) Observations zoologiques faites 4 bord de l’Astrolabe, en mai
1826, dans le Détroit de Gibraltar. Annales des Sciences naturelles 10(1): 5-239.
Ritter-Zahony R (1908) Chatognathen (Vol. 14). Denkschriften der Kaiserlichen Akademie
der Wissenschaften 84: 1-18.
Ritter-Zahony R (1909) Die Chaetognathen der Gazelle-Expedition. Zoologischer Anzeiger
34(26): e5.
Ritter-Zahony R (1910) Die Chatognathen. Fauna Arctica 5(1): 249-288.
Ritter-Zahony R (1911) Revision der Chaetognathan. Deutsche Sudpolar Expedition 1901-
1903. Band 13, Zoologie 5. Hft. 1: 1-72.
Russell FS (1936) Observations on the distribution of plankton animal indicators made on
Col. ET Peel’s yacht “St. George” in the mouth of the English Channel, July, 1935. Journal
of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 20(3): 507-522. https://doi.
org/10.1017/S0025315400058094
Slabber M (1769) Natuurkundige verlustigingen, behelzende microscopise waarneemingen van
de in-en uitlandse water-en land-dieren. In: J. Bosch (Ed.) Haarlem, 1-18.
Srinivasan M (1979) Taxonomy and Ecology of Chaetognatha of the west coast of India in
relation to their role as indicator organisms of water masses. Zoological Survey of India.
Technical Monograph 3: 1-47.
Sund PN (1961) Two new species of Chaetognatha from the waters off Peru. Pacific Science
15: 105-111.
Terazaki M (1992) Horizontal and vertical distribution of chaetognaths in a Kuroshio warm-
core ring. Deep-Sea Research. Part A, Oceanographic Research Papers 39: 231-245.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0198-0149(11)80014-2
Terazaki M (1998) Life history, distribution, seasonal variability and feeding of the pelagic
chaetognath Sagitta elegans in the Subarctic Pacific: A review. Plankton Biology and Ecol-
ogy 45(1): 1-17.
Thomson JM (1947) The chaetognaths of Southeastern Australia. Bulletin of the Council for
Scientific and Industrial Research Melbourne 222(14): |-43.
Tokioka T (1939) Chaetognaths collected chiefly from the Bays of Sagami and Suruga with
some notes on the shape and structure of the seminal vesicles. Records of Oceanographic
Works in Japan 10: 122-150.
A taxonomic reassessment of Aphragmophora from Korean water 211
Tokioka T (1940) The chaetognath fauna of the waters of western Japan. Records of Oceano-
graphic Works in Japan 12(22): e940.
Tokioka T (1951) Pelagic tunicates and chaetognaths collected during the cruises to the New
Yamato Bank in the Sea of Japan. Publications of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory
2(1): 1-25. https://doi.org/10.5134/174451
Tokioka T (1959) Observations on the taxonomy and distribution of chaetognaths of the North
Pacific. Publications of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory 7(3): 349-456. https://doi.
org/10.5134/174631
Tokioka T (1965a) The taxonomical outline of Chaetognatha. Publications of the Seto Marine
Biological Laboratory 12(5): 335-357. https://doi.org/10.5134/175381
Tokioka T (1965b) Supplementary notes on the systematics of Chaetognatha. Publications of
the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory 13(3): 231-242. https://doi.org/10.5134/175405
Tokioka T, Pathansali D (1963) A new form of Sagitta bedoti Beraneck found in the littoral
waters near Penang. Bulletin of the National Science Museum 33: 1-5.
Tse P, Hui SY, Wong CK (2007) Species composition and seasonal abundance of Chaetogna-
tha in the subtropical coastal waters of Hong Kong. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science
73(1-2): 290-298. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecss.2007.01.011
Verrill AE (1873) Report upon the invertebrate animals of Vineyard Sound and the adjacent
waters, with an account of the physical characters of the region. United States Commission
of Fish and Fisheries, Government Printing Office, Washington, 295-778. https://doi.
org/10.5962/bhL.title. 11688
Villenas EK Palma S (2006) Sagitta chilensis nueva especie de quetognato en fiordos australes
chilenos (Chaetognatha, Aphragmophora, Sagittidae). Investigaciones Marinas 34(1):
101-108. https://doi.org/10.4067/S0717-71782006000100009
WoRMS Editorial Board (2022) World Register of Marine Species. https://www.marinespecies.
org [at VLIZ] [Accessed 2021-12-24] https://doi.org/10.14284/170
Yoo KI (1991) Zooplankton studies of Yellow Sea in Korea. Yellow Sea Research (4): 31-37.
Yoo KI, Kim WR (1996) Spatial distribution of Chaetognaths in the Yellow Sea in the summer.
Korean Journal of Environmental Biology 14(2): 155-160.
Yoo KI, Kim WR (1997) Seasonal variation of Chaetognaths off Kori, Korea. Korean Journal
of Environmental Biology 15(1): 9-17.